Research note says AI hardware sell-off may be a bullwhip effect, with Japan and Taiwan only now catching up

Research note says AI hardware sell-off may be a bullwhip effect, with Japan and Taiwan only now catching up

N
News Editor
2026-10-19 09:26:08
A market note compiled by Chinese sell-side research firm Hongze Research argues that the recent drop in AI hardware stocks looks more like a high-volatility shakeout than a confirmed collapse, even as the sell-off has spread from China and South Korea to Japan and Taiwan. The report, based on investor interviews, says the Philadelphia semiconductor ETF SOXX was the last major link in the chain to weaken. The note points to three main pressures: tighter funding conditions as AI capital spending increasingly relies on external financing while long-dated US yields rise; a widening gap between falling model prices and sticky capital costs across the supply chain; and the market’s difficulty in proving AI returns outside software development. It also uses a "longer whip" analogy to explain why some parts of the supply chain, including companies such as ASML and TSMC, may react later than others. At the same time, the author says a crash case is not settled. The report cites counterarguments around rates, Anthropic’s IPO process, and Bridgewater’s view that AI spending has weakened the usual link between growth and interest rates. For now, the author’s conclusion is that the market is still in a high-volatility phase, though the decline may not be over.

AI hardware stocks have been sliding since the second half of September, first in China and South Korea and more recently in Japan and Taiwan, according to a note compiled by Chinese sell-side research firm Hongze Research from investor interviews. The report says the iShares Semiconductor ETF SOXX was the last major piece of the chain to turn weaker. The central debate, it says, is whether this is a mid-cycle break in the AI trade or a violent reshuffling inside an industry that is still moving forward. The author leans toward the second view, while adding that calling a top is "very difficult."

From a B-wave rebound to a sharp reversal

The note says AI hardware names turned lower from the tail end of a B-wave rebound, in Elliott wave terms, starting in mid-to-late July. China and South Korea rolled over first, followed later by Japan and Taiwan. There had already been a sell-off in July tied to crowded positioning, but the analyst argues that this round is being driven by something else. The factor cited most often in the market is high long-term US interest rates.

The report groups the market’s concerns into three areas.

  • Funding pressure: AI capital expenditure is increasingly dependent on outside financing just as long-dated US Treasury yields have risen quickly, intensifying competition for capital. The note says the funding structure and cost burden of companies such as CoreWeave have worsened noticeably, and that the July decline also began with unusual moves in CDS.
  • The gap between pricing and costs: If large language model companies fail to secure monopoly-like positions, prices are likely to fall, while CAPEX and operating costs cannot come down at the same pace. The supply chain is also still dealing with shortages in several areas.
  • Returns remain hard to prove: Outside software development, the market has yet to see a breakthrough AI application that clearly excites investors.

The analyst also refers to concerns previously raised by Paul Tudor Jones about global capital being consumed too quickly while assets keep expanding. In the author’s view, the old backdrop of simultaneous fiscal and monetary easing has changed after Warsh took office, and the large-scale buybacks and abundant cash flow that had supported markets are now under pressure.

Why Japan and Taiwan did not break earlier

To address the question of why ASML and Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co. (TSMC) still posted strong guidance for the quarter while Japanese and Taiwanese equities pulled back, the analyst uses China’s property market as an analogy. The argument is that US AI, no matter how polished the story looks, still rests on leverage. Buying land is one layer of leverage and running a business is another; the AI industry, the note says, also carries stacked layers of leverage and inventory.

The report points to the fact that Chinese property developers and building materials stocks peaked at different times. Companies at different points in the chain do not reverse together. It argues that the same structure exists in the AI supply chain today, with CoreWeave, Nvidia, ASML and TSMC sitting in different positions and therefore feeling the impact at different times and with different intensity.

The author says this does not mean a collapse is inevitable. The point is that the bullwhip effect takes time to travel through the chain. Japan and Taiwan did not fall earlier not only because of capital flows, but mainly because the "whip is longer," a shorthand for differences in leverage and supply-chain position.

The note adds that extreme divergence among neocloud providers is itself a signal. If funding tightens, confidence in AI returns weakens, long-end capital costs rise again and the financial condition of LLM companies deteriorates, volatility could be larger than the market expects.

The split view: turbulence or the start of a crash

The analyst also lays out the opposing case. One question is whether long-duration funding costs are a coincident indicator or a leading one. Another is that while historical crashes often came with rate hikes, high rates do not automatically produce a collapse. The note also says current Treasury yield levels do not appear to have derailed Anthropic’s IPO process, suggesting the market is adjusting to the rate environment. Bridgewater is cited as saying that because much of GDP growth now comes from AI spending, the usual relationship between the economy and interest rates has weakened.

The author compares the current debate with Nvidia and memory stocks in 2024. At that time, investors were also worried about whether cloud service providers could sustain CAPEX, whether rising long-dated yields would bite, and whether training compute was reaching saturation. Those concerns eased only after cloud revenue and inference demand started to validate the spending story. In that framework, the analyst sees AI return on investment more as a trigger than the root cause.

The note states: "Rising yields, weak ARR data, and anti-AI rhetoric ahead of the midterm election that could attract votes are combining to create the current high volatility. More evidence is still needed before calling this the start of a crash." It also says the US dollar has begun to show signs of weakening and that long-dated Treasury yields fell noticeably in the previous week, which the author reads as signs that conditions are moving away from extremes.

On timing, the author expects the market to fall before the midterm election and for the correction to end after the vote. The report says the election outcome itself may have limited impact. Even if Democrats were to win both chambers of Congress, the most that might happen is tighter limits on some unrealistic AI data-center plans.

Corporate adoption data is the next checkpoint

The analyst says the next key question is whether AI can show meaningful progress outside software development. To support the case that AI is already producing measurable gains, the note lists several data points: Palantir posted 93% revenue growth in the second quarter of 2026, with US commercial revenue up 149%; monday.com said ARR for its AI products doubled in a single quarter; Airbnb cut customer-service cost per booking by 16% year over year, with about 45% of complaints handled by AI; and Celonis customers have generated a cumulative $10 billion in measurable value.

The report groups enterprise AI use cases into three buckets.

  • Saving labor time: AI takes over repetitive and coordination-heavy work that used to consume staff time, allowing the same workforce to handle more tasks or shorten process cycles. The note gives Heineken’s supply-chain management and allocation work as an example.
  • Expanding usable capacity: Better scheduling and dispatching can make existing resources work harder, lifting service volume or revenue. One example cited is a medical center that can open more than 50 additional beds per month.
  • Plugging financial leaks: AI can reduce money that should not be leaving a business, including overpayments, mistaken payments and waste.

Three things the market is watching next

The author highlights three areas to watch. First is the US earnings season, which starts next week and will test both big tech performance and whether enterprise AI rollouts are progressing smoothly. That could ease doubts around AI returns. Second is market breadth. The note says the current pattern of indexes making new highs while fewer stocks rise points to a narrower market, and that the combination of high rates and broad corporate commitment to AI may raise the odds of a break. Third is capital flow. If SaaS-driven process improvements prove meaningful, and if those services are priced by project rather than by token, profits may shift away from hardware and toward outsourced project-based service providers.

The report’s conclusion is straightforward: until more evidence appears, the market looks more like it is in a high-volatility phase than in a confirmed collapse, but the decline may not be finished.

This article was originally published by Bit.Fan. For more cryptocurrency news and market insights, visit www.bit.fan.
10300

Disclaimer:

The market information, project data, and third-party content displayed on this platform are for industry information sharing only and do not constitute any form of investment advice or return commitment.

Cryptocurrency trading carries high risks. Users should fully assess their risk tolerance and make independent decisions. All profits, losses, and legal responsibilities are borne by the users themselves.

Research note says AI hardware sell-off may be a bullwhip effect, with Japan and Taiwan only now catching up | Bit.Fan