Chiang campaign’s Taipei Policy Island faces copycat claims; creator says interaction design referenced HEART Policy Island

Chiang campaign’s Taipei Policy Island faces copycat claims; creator says interaction design referenced HEART Policy Island

N
News Editor
2026-10-28 15:47:41
A dispute over AI-built 3D campaign websites has broken out in Taipei’s mayoral race after Chiang Wan-an’s campaign unveiled the interactive “Taipei Policy Island” on Oct. 28. The site was quickly accused of copying Democratic Progressive Party candidate Puma Shen’s “HEART Policy Island,” which went live late on Oct. 22 and presented 14 policy themes and 94 policy items as a navigable 3D island. Chain News reviewed public GitHub records and found that the project at the center of the controversy, listed as channel No. 2034 on the Encore Taipei platform, included a prompt explicitly saying its “interactive feel” should reference puma.taipei/heart-island. Public commit records also show a sequence in which Chiang ally Ko Ju-chun’s earlier ai2033.taipei project began on Oct. 9, while Encore Taipei started on Oct. 23 at 00:53 and the separate “Taipei Policy Island” repository under another account logged its first commit at 06:25 the same day. Late on Oct. 28, the site’s creator revised the project description, acknowledging that the interaction format, including the island map, category numbering and timeline, referenced HEART Policy Island, while saying the code itself did not reuse HEART’s codebase and that policy fact-checking and city governance materials were compiled separately with public sources attached.

Taipei’s mayoral race just picked up a fight over AI-made 3D campaign websites. It started after Chiang Wan-an’s campaign headquarters rolled out the interactive “Taipei Policy Island” site on Oct. 28. Very quickly, people accused it of copying Democratic Progressive Party Taipei mayoral candidate Puma Shen’s “HEART Policy Island.”

The dispute centers on the “Taipei Policy Island” project

After checking public GitHub records from both camps, Chain News said the argument came down to channel No. 2034, “Taipei Policy Island,” on the Encore Taipei platform. The production prompt for that project did, in fact, say it referenced Policy Island. And on the evening of Oct. 28, the creator of Taipei Policy Island updated the site description to admit the interaction format had referenced the earlier project.

Shen announced “HEART Policy Island” late on Oct. 22. The site turned 14 policy themes and 94 policy sub-items into a 3D island users could roam freely. According to a SET News report, the website drew more than 100,000 likes within eight hours after launch.

Ko Ju-chun said work began in early October, but the timeline was challenged

Kuomintang lawmaker Ko Ju-chun, who serves as SI chief executive for Chiang’s campaign headquarters, posted on Threads on Oct. 28 to announce the launch of “Taipei Encore Stage.” He said he had used Claude Opus 5.5 with Three.js in early October to build a “Taipei AI Park virtual experience.” He also wrote that he was “also happy to see Legislator Puma Shen’s team follow up and use the same Claude + Three.js technology to launch a ‘policy cartoon island.’”

Users pushed back fast. They pointed to the repository history and replied: “Your first commit was made on 10/23, and you still say Puma Shen’s team ‘followed up’?” The report explained that a commit is each saved record of code on GitHub, and the first commit time can be treated as the project’s start time.

Public prompt explicitly referenced HEART Policy Island

ETtoday reported that the creator of Policy Island said the prompt given to the AI on Encore Taipei directly told it to reference Policy Island. A screenshot published by ETtoday showed the opening line in the “prompt used to make this channel” field on the page for channel No. 2034, “Taipei Policy Island”:

“Help me make a 3D interactive website that presents the municipal achievements and policy proposals from Taipei Mayor Chiang Wan-an’s 2022–2026 term in the form of an ‘island map,’ with interaction feel referencing puma.taipei/heart-island.”

The URL puma.taipei/heart-island is Shen’s HEART Policy Island address. ETtoday said that prompt was publicly visible on the Encore Taipei page.

GitHub records show the sequence of three related projects

The dispute involves three websites. All three have public GitHub records. Chain News compared the first commit times for each project in Taiwan time:

WebsiteGitHub projectFirst commit
ai2033.taipei (Taipei AI Park virtual experience)dAAAb/ai2033.taipeiOct. 9
HEART Policy Island launch—Late on Oct. 22
encore.taipei (Taipei Encore Stage)dAAAb/encore-taipeiOct. 23, 00:53
Taipei Policy Island (Encore Taipei channel No. 2034)bounce12340/chiang-wanan-policy-islandOct. 23, 06:25

dAAAb is Ko’s GitHub account. His ai2033.taipei project really did start on Oct. 9, before HEART Policy Island. But that project was a 3D driving experience in Taipei showing Songshan Airport transformed into an AI park, not an island-map presentation. Different thing.

The Encore Taipei platform itself came after HEART Policy Island was already live. Public production records show the first request was submitted at 00:23 on Oct. 23. That request asked for a 3D Taipei nightclub set in 2033, styled like an illustration website, with Chiang dancing on stage. No mention of Policy Island. Chain News said it searched the project’s full commit history and did not find the Policy Island URL there.

Creator revised the site description on the night of Oct. 28

The project accused of referencing Policy Island was channel No. 2034, “Taipei Policy Island.” On GitHub, a project with the same name and the same 3D information-map concept for Chiang’s governance record and policy proposals appears under another account, bounce12340, whose display name is Josh Tsai. Its first commit was made on the morning of Oct. 23, the day after HEART Policy Island launched. The report said the commit records of the two projects showed no overlap between that account and Ko’s account.

The original site description for Taipei Policy Island said: “The interactive concept references ‘Policy Island’-style information visualization websites, while the code and models were all written by this site itself.”

At 10:24 p.m. on Oct. 28, the creator added a new commit titled “Added HEART reference source and AI production explanation (correcting ‘written by itself’)” and inserted a correction section on the website saying:

“This site’s interactive format — island map, category numbering, timeline, and so on — references HEART Policy Island, which went live on 2026/10/22. Thanks to the HEART team for first putting together such a strong example.”

The correction also said the site’s code was written by the creator with AI assistance using Claude Code, and that the earlier wording claiming the “code and models were all written by this site itself” was not accurate enough. It also said the code did not reuse HEART, while policy verification and city governance materials were compiled separately by the creator, with public sources attached to each item.

Ko said most channels were co-created by users and AI

ETtoday said Ko rejected the plagiarism claim at a press conference, arguing it was “a campaign rival using the same method as us to make this kind of 3D test webpage.”

When asked about the prompt for channel No. 2034, Ko said: “Most published channels are co-created by internet users and AI, and the 2034 channel you mentioned is too; we do not interfere with any creator, we simply aggregate them.” Production records for Encore Taipei also say that citizen-submitted channels are reviewed by Ko before publication.

ETtoday also reported that the interactive “Taipei Policy Island” website was the project Chiang’s campaign headquarters presented at its Oct. 28 press conference.

This article was originally published by Bit.Fan. For more cryptocurrency news and market insights, visit www.bit.fan.
5400

Disclaimer:

The market information, project data, and third-party content displayed on this platform are for industry information sharing only and do not constitute any form of investment advice or return commitment.

Cryptocurrency trading carries high risks. Users should fully assess their risk tolerance and make independent decisions. All profits, losses, and legal responsibilities are borne by the users themselves.