Hardware wallet incidents revive debate over whether crypto self-custody works for beginners

Hardware wallet incidents revive debate over whether crypto self-custody works for beginners

N
News Editor
2026-10-23 11:47:47
Recent security incidents involving Ledger and Coldcard have reopened a long-running argument in crypto: was self-custody ever built for beginners in the first place? Industry executives interviewed by Cointelegraph offered sharply different answers. Onramp CEO Michael Tanguma said self-custody was never designed with newcomers in mind, comparing Bitcoin custody today to personal computers in the 1970s, when users needed technical skill just to get started. Safe Labs CEO Rahul Rumalla took the opposite view, arguing that self-custody was always meant for everyone and that users should not need to become security experts to control their own assets. The discussion extends beyond hardware wallets themselves. Multisignature wallets can raise security by requiring multiple approvals, but they also add coordination, backup and recovery burdens that may be hard for beginners to manage. Seedless wallet designs remove the need to store a recovery phrase, yet they shift risk toward physical device custody and transaction verification. Tangem said losing all linked devices would permanently lock users out, while Foundation CEO Zach Herbert warned that users can still be tricked into approving malicious transactions even if private keys remain secure.

Recent security incidents involving hardware wallets have revived debate over whether crypto self-custody is suitable for beginners. Executives across the industry are split on the question, while alternatives such as multisignature wallets and seedless backup systems come with their own trade-offs in security and usability.

Safe Labs CEO Rahul Rumalla told Cointelegraph, 「We don’t expect every driver to be a mechanic, and we shouldn’t expect everyone who wants to own their assets to become a security expert.」

Making self-custody easier to use could matter for broader Bitcoin adoption, since the ability to 「be your own bank」 remains one of the asset’s defining ideas.

Recent incidents tied to Ledger and Coldcard have also highlighted weaknesses in hardware wallets, which are widely recommended as one of the safest ways to hold crypto because private keys stay offline.

Implants in some Ledger devices stole recovery phrases, while a Coldcard firmware bug allowed attackers to recreate private keys and steal funds.

Michael Tanguma, CEO of Bitcoin custody provider Onramp, compared Bitcoin custody to personal computers in the 1970s, when users needed technical skills to assemble and operate them.

「Self-custody was never designed with newcomers in mind,」 he told Cointelegraph.

Tanguma said simpler designs helped computers reach a wider audience, and that Bitcoin custody now faces a similar challenge.

Trezor Model One, described as the world’s first hardware wallet, was released in 2014. Source: Trezor.

Multisig raises security, but adds complexity

Rumalla disagreed with the idea that self-custody was not built for ordinary users. He said self-custody was 「always meant for everyone」 and added that 「being able to own and control your assets is the whole point of crypto.」

He also said self-custody 「does not mean doing everything yourself.」

Multisignature, or multisig, wallets require multiple keys to authorize transactions, but that structure can be difficult for beginners to manage.

Justin Hutzler, chief technology officer of Synergy Network, said, 「Traditional multisig implementations can introduce additional complexity involving signer coordination, key backups, recovery procedures, and transaction approvals.」

BitGo has illustrated the difference between single-signature and multisig setups.

Even so, multiple approvals do not stop every kind of attack.

Rumalla said several signers could still approve a malicious transaction if they were all misled by the same compromised interface.

Seedless wallets remove one problem and create others

Tangem said its seedless design simplifies self-custody by removing the need to manage a recovery phrase. In exchange, users must protect the physical devices that provide access to their funds.

A private key is generated on one card, with backup copies stored on as many as two additional devices. Tangem confirmed to Cointelegraph that if a user loses every device, access to the funds would be permanently lost.

The company said it had received no reports of users losing all of their cards.

But keeping the cards safe does not protect users from approving a malicious transaction. Zach Herbert, CEO of rival hardware wallet maker Foundation, said seedless backups can preserve self-custody, but criticized Tangem for lacking a built-in screen, leaving users dependent on their smartphones to verify transaction details.

「An attacker does not need to extract your private key if they can trick you into authorizing a transaction that empties your wallet,」 he said.

This article was originally published by Bit.Fan. For more cryptocurrency news and market insights, visit www.bit.fan.
11200

Disclaimer:

The market information, project data, and third-party content displayed on this platform are for industry information sharing only and do not constitute any form of investment advice or return commitment.

Cryptocurrency trading carries high risks. Users should fully assess their risk tolerance and make independent decisions. All profits, losses, and legal responsibilities are borne by the users themselves.