Jason Pagoulatos, head of markets at Delphi Digital, said on the Oct. 22 episode of Unchained that Papertrade was right to worry about the risks tied to making its PAPER token freely tradable, but changing the terms after users had already pre-deposited roughly $140 million left the project looking bad.
Pagoulatos said the move was not exactly a rug, though he described it as a kind of bait and switch for users who joined under an earlier rule set. In his telling, people were sold on one framework, money came in, and the framework was then changed after the fact.
Papertrade pulled back from transferability after launch
Papertrade, a high-leverage trading venue on Hyperliquid’s HyperEVM network, went live on Oct. 10. On Oct. 19, the team said that “at this juncture” it did not plan to allow off-contract token transferability.
That stance marked a shift from the project’s Oct. 1 launch plan, which had listed transfers as a later phase. Under the platform’s design, traders earn PAPER when they lose money and can stake the token for a share of fees.
Team says a short market would make manipulation profitable
Papertrade said the core issue is that a market for shorting PAPER would create an incentive structure that rewards price manipulation. In a hypothetical example, the team wrote that an attack costing $15 million to manipulate the price of bitcoin or ether would not be viable on its own for someone with a $10 million bankroll. Add a $10 million PAPER short, it said, and the same attack becomes “very viable indeed.”
Pagoulatos agreed with that assessment. He said an attack “will 100% happen” if the token becomes transferable because anyone can quickly create a perp market, adding that the first part of that dynamic had already appeared on launch day.
He said the team manually blocked positions tied to large Hyperliquid market orders that moved ether’s price that day.
Paragon listed a PAPER perp, then halted it shortly after
On Oct. 18, Paragon listed a PAPER perpetual on Hyperliquid through HIP-3, the network’s system for third-party markets. About a minute after Papertrade published its post, Paragon halted the market and settled it.
Pagoulatos also said that capping pool size or leverage as a way to reduce risk would strip away much of the reason users would choose Papertrade in the first place.
At the same time, he noted that the team had explicitly flagged the risk in its documentation ahead of time, and said responsibility does not sit with only one side.
Staking payouts dropped, then rebounded
According to DefiLlama, Papertrade had distributed about $57 million to PAPER stakers through Oct. 21.
Daily payouts fell from about $1.3 million on Oct. 20 to roughly $88,000 on Oct. 21, then recovered to about $1.07 million on Oct. 22.
Pagoulatos said current activity looks more like organic usage from people who actually want this type of product, rather than users who arrived mainly to farm a token and later sell it. He said he would not say the story is over, but added that the road ahead will be extremely tough.


