MSCI’s new screening rules put Strategy and four others at risk of index removal

MSCI’s new screening rules put Strategy and four others at risk of index removal

N
News Editor
2026-10-19 02:32:14
MSCI is set to apply a new screening framework for what it calls "non-operating companies" in its November index review, with final affected names due on Nov. 11 and changes taking effect after the Nov. 30 close. The shift matters for a cluster of listed crypto treasury firms because the index provider is no longer focusing only on how much digital assets a company holds. Instead, it will assess whether a company has enough operating substance through measures tied to operating assets, operating expenses, cash flow, fair-value changes and reliance on external financing. Five companies are currently on the potential deletion list, including three tied to crypto treasury strategies: Strategy, Metaplanet and Upexi. Another 17 companies, including SharpLink, SUI Group Holdings, TON Strategy and Solana Company, are on a watchlist. The debate goes beyond passive fund outflows. For treasury companies that raise capital through equity, bonds or preferred stock to buy crypto, index exclusion could also affect valuation premiums and, in turn, the efficiency of future fundraising. Strategy has argued the impact would be limited, while critics of the framework say it treats Bitcoin differently from other capital assets.

MSCI will adopt a new screening framework for "non-operating companies" in its November index review, putting Strategy, Metaplanet and Upexi among the crypto treasury-related firms facing possible removal from global indexes. The final list is scheduled for Nov. 11, and any changes will take effect after the market close on Nov. 30.

MSCI’s new screening rules put Strategy and four others at risk of index removal 2

The new approach shifts the test away from a single focus on digital-asset exposure. Instead, MSCI will look at whether a listed company functions more like an operating business or more like an investment vehicle based on its broader financial structure.

From a digital-asset threshold to a broader operating-substance test

On Oct. 15, MSCI said it would adopt the new framework, using measures such as operating assets, operating expenses and cash flow to identify companies it considers non-operating. The changes will be implemented as part of the November index review.

In 2025, MSCI had proposed excluding treasury companies from the Global Investable Market Indexes, or GIMI, if digital assets accounted for 50% or more of total assets. In January this year, however, it decided not to implement that exclusion and instead moved to study a broader framework covering non-operating companies across asset classes.

That means last year’s 50% digital-asset ratio was never an automatic deletion line in force. The companies involved remained in the indexes, though they were subject to temporary restrictions, including freezes on increases in index shares and inclusion factors, as well as delays in new additions and size-segment migrations.

The new framework replaces those temporary measures. MSCI is no longer judging companies solely by digital-asset concentration and will instead review overall financial structure, whether the assets held are crypto or more traditional investment assets.

A two-step process

The framework starts with asset structure, then moves to business activity and funding sources.

The first step is a core screen that asks whether a company has enough operating assets. Under MSCI’s consultation document, a company passes this stage if operating assets account for more than 50% of total assets. If it falls short, it moves to a second stage.

The second stage uses five financial indicators:

  • operating assets, or how much of the balance sheet is actually used in business activity;
  • operating expenses, or whether spending is consistent with the scale of the asset base;
  • operating cash flow, or whether the business generates cash;
  • fair-value changes, or whether financial performance is driven mainly by swings in asset prices;
  • reliance on external financing, or whether asset accumulation depends primarily on raising capital.

If a company fails the core screen and triggers exclusion conditions on at least four of the five indicators, it will be deemed ineligible for inclusion.

MSCI also built in a buffer. Existing constituents are removed only if they fail the screen in both of the two most recent annual reporting periods. Non-constituents, by contrast, are not eligible for new inclusion if they fail in either of the two most recent annual reporting periods. MSCI may also refer to the latest interim filings.

In practice, keeping a small software or hotel business may not be enough to preserve index eligibility, while holding a large amount of crypto does not automatically trigger deletion. The key question is how much weight operating business carries in the company’s overall financial structure and whether any non-compliant pattern persists.

Five names face possible deletion, 17 are on watch

MSCI’s disclosed potential deletion list currently includes five companies. Three are tied to crypto treasury strategies: Bitcoin holder Strategy, Metaplanet and Upexi, which is focused primarily on a SOL treasury strategy. The other two are uranium investment company Yellow Cake and Icelandic investment holding company Skel fjárfestingafélag.

The watchlist has expanded to 17 companies, including SharpLink, SUI Group Holdings, TON Strategy and Solana Company, all linked in some way to digital-asset treasury strategies.

The two lists reflect different stages of risk. Companies on the potential deletion list still need to be confirmed in the November review. Those on the watchlist have not yet met the threshold for removal, but could be taken out later if they continue to fail the screen.

Why the financing angle may matter more than passive selling

Index membership has a direct effect on passive allocations. Once a company is removed, funds tracking the relevant indexes need to rebalance, which can create concentrated selling pressure.

Because of its size, Strategy has drawn the most attention. JPMorgan previously estimated that if MSCI removes the company, it could face about $2.8 billion in outflows. If other major index providers follow, that figure could rise to about $8.8 billion.

Strategy has pushed back on the significance of that risk. The company said funds tracking MSCI GIMI hold about 13 million shares of MSTR, equal to 3.1% of basic shares outstanding and roughly 60% of its 30-day average daily trading volume, and argued that the adjustment would not have a material effect.

Still, trading volume is not the same thing as the market’s capacity to absorb net selling. For treasury companies, the longer-term issue may be whether index exclusion compresses valuation premiums and reduces the efficiency of raising capital to buy more crypto.

These companies often issue stock, bonds or preferred shares and then use the proceeds to acquire digital assets. When common shares trade at a sizable premium to net asset value, issuing equity can more easily increase the amount of assets backing each share. If that premium narrows, the same amount of fundraising requires more share issuance, making dilution more visible for existing holders.

So the impact of the new rules is not limited to how many shares passive funds may sell during rebalancing. It also reaches the question of whether treasury companies can keep raising money on favorable terms. If they lean more heavily on debt or preferred stock, they also take on interest, dividend and repayment obligations.

The dispute over what counts as an operating business

The core disagreement between treasury companies and MSCI is whether raising capital, holding crypto and issuing financial products amount to real operating substance.

Strategy argues that it is not simply passively holding Bitcoin. The company says it runs financing and financial-product activities on top of its Bitcoin position, notes that its Bitcoin business is disclosed as an operating segment under U.S. GAAP, and accuses MSCI of repackaging an earlier exclusion plan aimed at digital-asset treasury companies.

In an interview with Bloomberg, Saylor said the amount of money tracking the relevant indexes is limited and that removal would have little effect on Strategy. He also challenged MSCI’s treatment of different assets, saying, 「Oil, gas, land, and machines all count as capital, but Bitcoin does not.」 In his view, that reflects bias against Bitcoin.

Under MSCI’s logic, though, carrying out those activities does not automatically preserve index eligibility. If a company’s assets are still mainly investment holdings, if financial performance still moves largely with asset prices, and if expansion still depends on external financing, the company may still be classified as non-operating even if it actively trades and issues securities.

Metaplanet has tried to show treasury-management capability through actual trading. In the third quarter, it sold 10,000 BTC and later bought 11,000 BTC, saying the move was meant to demonstrate Bitcoin liquidity and its ability to cover interest-bearing debt.

But liquidity is not the same as operating capability. Selling Bitcoin for cash does not mean a core business can generate recurring cash flow. Buying back more Bitcoin does not necessarily change a structure in which assets are still dominated by investment holdings and expansion still relies on financing. Whether those actions help under the new framework depends on how they show up in the financial indicators.

November will provide the first real test

MSCI’s new rules do not directly end the treasury-company model, but they could weaken index-fund support for it. The final list in November will determine which companies leave the indexes.

Over a longer horizon, if valuation premiums narrow, treasury companies may need to show they can keep increasing net asset value per common share even if the efficiency of financing crypto purchases declines.

This article was originally published by Bit.Fan. For more cryptocurrency news and market insights, visit www.bit.fan.
10000

Disclaimer:

The market information, project data, and third-party content displayed on this platform are for industry information sharing only and do not constitute any form of investment advice or return commitment.

Cryptocurrency trading carries high risks. Users should fully assess their risk tolerance and make independent decisions. All profits, losses, and legal responsibilities are borne by the users themselves.