Robinhood CEO says SEC’s five-year exemption is too short for tokenized stocks

Robinhood CEO says SEC’s five-year exemption is too short for tokenized stocks

N
News Editor
2026-10-30 01:32:18
Robinhood CEO Vlad Tenev said the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission’s innovation exemption is a constructive step for tokenized stocks, but a five-year window is still too short to give large issuers confidence to move core assets on-chain. Speaking on the company’s third-quarter earnings call, Tenev said the problem is not that the rules are too strict, but that the framework remains too temporary for major asset issuers to rely on. The issue cuts directly into Robinhood’s current tokenized equity model. The SEC’s exemption requires tokenized shares to carry the same rights and privileges as traditional shares, including dividends and voting rights. Robinhood, however, has disclosed that its tokenized U.S. equities in the European Union provide economic exposure rather than shareholder status. That gap has become central to the debate. The comments came as Robinhood reported weaker crypto results for the quarter. Total net revenue rose 12% year over year to $1.28 billion, but crypto-related revenue fell 55% to $268 million. Crypto notional trading volume dropped 38% to $42.2 billion, while app trading volume and Bitstamp volume also declined. The contrast between Robinhood’s tokenization push and its current crypto revenue trend has drawn fresh attention to whether tokenized equities can become a meaningful business line in the near term.

Robinhood CEO Vlad Tenev said the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission’s innovation exemption is a positive step, but a five-year term is not long enough to give large issuers confidence to move core assets on-chain. The remarks came as Robinhood’s third-quarter results showed crypto-related revenue fell 55% from a year earlier, putting the company’s tokenization push next to a much weaker set of near-term operating numbers.

Tenev says five years is too short for major issuers

Speaking on Robinhood’s third-quarter earnings call, Tenev said large issuers the company has spoken with have repeatedly told Robinhood that a five-year regulatory window is too short for them to feel comfortable moving important assets onto blockchain rails. He said the key issue is not looser regulation, but a durable and predictable framework, whether that comes through legislation or formal rulemaking.

Tenev also backed the current policy direction, saying Robinhood supports efforts by the administration and the SEC to advance the innovation exemption. Even so, he described the exemption as a transitional arrangement rather than a lasting foundation. The market paid close attention to the comments because Robinhood is one of the most active promoters of tokenized equities, and the long-term viability of that product structure depends heavily on how much regulatory certainty Washington is willing to provide.

The SEC requires equal rights, while Robinhood offers economic exposure

Under the SEC’s published innovation exemption, tokenized stocks must carry the same rights and privileges as traditional shares to qualify as compliant products. That includes the right to receive dividends and the right to vote.

That requirement creates a direct problem for Robinhood’s current structure. In the European Union, Robinhood issues tokenized U.S. equities through a special-purpose broker-dealer, allowing European users to trade more than 2,000 tokenized U.S. stocks. But by the company’s own disclosure, those tokens provide economic exposure rather than shareholder status. In practical terms, the token can track price moves, while voting rights and dividend claims do not sit on the same footing. That is the gap at the center of the SEC’s equal-rights standard.

Earlier this month, Robinhood said it would also issue tokens representing equity in private companies, with OpenAI named in the first batch, and trade those tokens on its own blockchain. That move pushed the debate beyond listed equities and into private-company shares, where the regulatory challenge is even harder. The underlying assets do not have public market prices or fixed disclosure obligations, and there is still no standard answer for how investors can verify that a token actually corresponds to an equity interest.

More than a dozen listed companies have objected

Opposition arrived quickly. More than a dozen listed companies, including AMC and GameStop, have submitted comments to the SEC opposing a structure that would allow third parties to package their shares into on-chain tokens.

Their position is broadly the same: companies are under no obligation to endorse tokens tied to their own shares when those tokens are issued by outside parties on-chain, and such a structure would bypass corporate control over shareholder registries and voting procedures. Tenev has already pushed back on that argument in public, saying companies do not have the authority to veto on-chain stock tokens. The two sides remain far apart.

A small market today, with much larger forecasts for 2030

For now, the tokenized stock market remains small in absolute terms. As of Sept. 15, the global tokenized stock market had a total market value of about $4.43 billion. In January 2025, that figure was only $2.28 million. The growth rate is striking, but the starting base was extremely low.

Binance Research, in its real-world asset research, estimated under a base-case scenario that the tokenized stock market could expand to $349 billion by 2030. Even at that level, compared with roughly $151.9 trillion in global listed equity market value, penetration would still be below 0.003%.

The significance of those figures is that the market is not yet large enough to force issuers to change their position, but it is already large enough that regulators have to state where they stand. If the kind of “serious assets” Tenev referred to are ever going to move on-chain, accounting, tax treatment, shareholder rights and cross-border settlement would all need a stable rule set lasting at least five to ten years. That is the missing piece right now.

Robinhood’s crypto revenue fell 55% in the third quarter

Robinhood reported total net revenue of $1.28 billion in the third quarter, up 12% from a year earlier. Crypto-related revenue came in at $268 million, down 55% year over year. Crypto notional trading volume was $42.2 billion, down 38%.

Within that, Robinhood App trading volume fell 48% to $32.2 billion, while trading volume at Bitstamp, the exchange it owns, declined 28% to $10 billion. Event contracts revenue, by contrast, reached $25 million, six times the level from a year earlier, making it one of the few business lines that posted strong growth.

Robinhood has not published monthly operating metrics since April, leaving the market to piece together the trend from quarterly filings. That makes the 55% drop in crypto revenue stand out even more. The company continues to push tokenization and other on-chain products, but the short-term financial contribution has not offset the gap left by softer crypto trading activity. Robinhood shares weakened in after-hours trading after the earnings release and Tenev’s comments.

The bottleneck sits with issuers, not trading infrastructure

Put Tenev’s comments next to the earnings figures, and the current bottleneck in tokenized stocks looks different from what many expected. The trading side is largely in place. On-chain matching, 24-hour trading and cross-border wallet settlement are not the main constraint, and platforms such as Robinhood and Coinbase have already built much of the necessary infrastructure.

The real hold-up is on the issuance side: whether listed companies and private firms that control shareholder registries are willing to recognize the rights represented by on-chain tokens. That is why the SEC’s equal-rights requirement matters so much. On the surface, it asks for dividends and voting rights. In practice, it means issuers would have to let part of the shareholder registry be handled through on-chain intermediaries. For companies worth tens of billions of dollars, that is a change to internal controls and compliance systems, not something solved by adding an API. On that scale, a five-year exemption period looks short.

From an investor perspective, tokenization currently looks more like a valuation catalyst than a revenue engine. Robinhood’s 55% drop in crypto revenue and broad trading-volume declines show that fees remain the core of the business. Tokenized equities may need several more quarters before they show up in the financials as a meaningful line item. Event contracts, with revenue up sixfold, have so far produced clearer results.

This article was originally published by Bit.Fan. For more cryptocurrency news and market insights, visit www.bit.fan.
5300

Disclaimer:

The market information, project data, and third-party content displayed on this platform are for industry information sharing only and do not constitute any form of investment advice or return commitment.

Cryptocurrency trading carries high risks. Users should fully assess their risk tolerance and make independent decisions. All profits, losses, and legal responsibilities are borne by the users themselves.