Strategy Faces Possible MSCI Removal as $2.8 Billion in Passive Flows Comes Into Focus

Strategy Faces Possible MSCI Removal as $2.8 Billion in Passive Flows Comes Into Focus

N
News Editor
2026-10-19 05:35:47
Strategy, the largest corporate holder of Bitcoin, has been placed on a potential removal list under new MSCI rules that screen whether index constituents qualify as operating companies. The index provider said companies that fail an initial review may face five financial ratio tests, and those triggering at least four exclusion conditions could lose eligibility. Strategy remains part of indexes including MSCI USA and MSCI World, according to Reuters, but the company has previously warned that exclusion could force passive funds tracking those benchmarks to sell about $2.8 billion worth of MSTR shares. The stock closed at $136.83 on Oct. 16, down 9.56% on the day. Strategy disclosed on Oct. 12 that it held 848,250 BTC, equal to about 4.04% of Bitcoin’s 21 million supply cap. Using Binance pricing of roughly $82,593 on Oct. 19, that stash was worth about $70.06 billion, above the company’s roughly $64.3 billion equity market value from the prior trading day. Reuters also said Metaplanet and SharpLink are among other companies being watched under the new framework.

Strategy (MSTR), the world’s largest corporate Bitcoin holder, is facing the risk of being removed from MSCI equity indexes after the index provider approved new rules on Oct. 15 that exclude companies that do not meet its definition of an operating business from the Global Investable Market Indexes.

Strategy has been placed on a potential removal list. If it ultimately loses index eligibility, passive funds tracking the affected benchmarks may need to sell about $2.8 billion of MSTR shares.

MSCI rule change puts Strategy’s status under review

According to MSCI’s announcement, the new framework examines whether a company has substantive operating assets. Companies that fail the first stage of review must then go through five financial ratio tests. If at least four of those tests hit exclusion thresholds, the company may lose index eligibility.

To limit frequent turnover in index constituents, existing members generally must fail the relevant tests in both of the most recent annual reporting periods before they are removed.

MSCI had previously imposed a temporary restriction on companies whose digital asset holdings accounted for at least 50% of total assets. Under the new rules, the decision will be based on broader financial indicators rather than a simple cutoff tied to large Bitcoin holdings.

Potential selling pressure is tied to passive funds, not forced BTC sales

Reuters reported that Strategy remains a constituent of indexes including MSCI USA and MSCI World. The company has previously warned that if it is excluded, passive funds tracking those indexes may need to sell about $2.8 billion worth of MSTR stock.

The development hit the shares. MSTR closed at $136.83 on Oct. 16, down 9.56% for the day.

That $2.8 billion figure is only a scenario-based estimate of potential stock sales. The actual amount would depend on the final index list, the share price, and fund allocations. The report also noted that sales of MSTR by passive vehicles such as ETFs do not mean Strategy itself would have to sell an equivalent amount of Bitcoin.

848,250 BTC holdings sharpen the debate over Strategy’s business profile

In an Oct. 12 disclosure, Strategy said it held 848,250 BTC, equal to about 4.04% of Bitcoin’s 21 million supply cap.

Using Binance pricing of about $82,593 on Oct. 19, the company’s Bitcoin position was worth about $70.06 billion. That was larger than its roughly $64.3 billion stock market value from the previous trading day.

Strategy’s model is to raise capital through stock issuance, preferred shares, and other financial instruments, then continue buying Bitcoin. That leaves the stock carrying characteristics of both corporate equity and a Bitcoin exposure vehicle.

Strategy disputes the idea that a Bitcoin treasury company should be treated as a passive investment vehicle. It argues that the company still operates a corporate software business and actively manages capital. The dispute centers on a basic question: MSCI wants equity indexes to represent companies with real operating activity, while Strategy says its Bitcoin treasury strategy is itself a core part of how the company operates.

Metaplanet and SharpLink are also in view

The scope of the rule change goes beyond Strategy. Reuters reported that Japan-based Bitcoin treasury company Metaplanet is also on the potential removal list, while Ether treasury company SharpLink (SBET) is on the watchlist.

MSCI is scheduled to publish the final list of affected companies on Nov. 11. The new rules take effect after the close on Nov. 30, and related index changes will be reflected starting Dec. 1.

For Strategy, the issue goes beyond short-term share price pressure. If losing index eligibility reduces demand for the stock and raises the cost of equity financing, the company’s ability to keep raising capital in public markets and continue buying BTC could be weakened.

This article was originally published by Bit.Fan. For more cryptocurrency news and market insights, visit www.bit.fan.
17800

Disclaimer:

The market information, project data, and third-party content displayed on this platform are for industry information sharing only and do not constitute any form of investment advice or return commitment.

Cryptocurrency trading carries high risks. Users should fully assess their risk tolerance and make independent decisions. All profits, losses, and legal responsibilities are borne by the users themselves.

Strategy Faces Possible MSCI Removal as $2.8 Billion in Passive Flows Comes Into Focus | Bit.Fan