US spot Ether exchange-traded funds recorded about $1.607 billion in net outflows in October through Oct. 30, based on daily figures cited from Farside Investors. BlackRock's ETHA made up about $1.42 billion of that total, or close to 90%.
The article says 19 of 22 trading days in October showed net outflows, while three days posted net inflows. It also pushes back on a widely circulated claim of 23 straight days of outflows, noting that Farside's daily table showed small inflows on Oct. 13, Oct. 21 and Oct. 23.
ETHA carried most of the month's redemptions
On Oct. 6, ETHA posted a single-day outflow of $201.9 million. That was also the day the fund carried out a 1-for-3 reverse split. According to an SEC filing cited in the article, fractional shares were to be settled in cash, which means the day's number was affected by the corporate action.
Still, the article argues that one reverse split cannot explain a full month of withdrawals. It points to continued ETHA outflows on Oct. 7, 12, 14, 19, 22 and through the end of the month.
Flows at other issuers were mixed. Fidelity's FETH posted about $36 million in net inflows in October. Grayscale's ETHE saw about $119 million in net outflows, while BlackRock's own ETHB lost about $52.3 million. On that basis, the article says the month did not look like a universal retreat from Ether exposure. It looked more like investors were rethinking how they wanted to hold ETH.
Who sold is not disclosed in the flow data
The piece draws a line between an ETF issuer and the investors who own fund shares. Calling the move "BlackRock selling ETH" is, in its view, inaccurate. ETHA is issued by BlackRock, but the shares are held by investors. The parties redeeming shares are the holders, which may include institutions and authorized participants engaged in creation-redemption arbitrage.
Once redemptions happen, the ETH behind those shares may be sold or handled by authorized participants, so the spot market can still be affected. But Farside reports dollar amounts, not names. The data set does not identify who redeemed.
The same limitation applies to the destination of the money. The article says the data can prove ETHA saw outflows, but not where the capital went next. For that, it points to quarterly holdings disclosures such as 13F filings.
Macro pressure offers one clue, but not the full answer
The article cites a Wintermute analysis dated Oct. 12 saying minutes from the Federal Reserve strengthened expectations that rates could still rise by year-end. At the same time, the 10-year US Treasury yield remained elevated and the S&P 500 was making new highs. During that week, US spot Bitcoin ETFs saw about $680 million in outflows and spot Ether ETFs lost about $540 million.
Its reading is that higher rates tend to weigh on assets without cash flow, and Bitcoin was not spared either. On price action, it cites Cointelegraph as reporting that ETH had fallen from about $2,700 to $2,438 by Oct. 21, a decline of 9.7%.
Even so, the article stops short of assigning a clean cause-and-effect relationship between price declines and ETF redemptions. The two moved together, but the timing alone does not settle which drove which. It also notes that if macro conditions were the whole story, they should have hit all products more evenly. That leaves ETHA's concentration of outflows as a product-level question as well.
ETHA offers price exposure, but not staking income
The article's main product argument is simple: ETHA gives investors exposure to ETH price moves, but not to the staking rewards that direct ETH holders may earn. Buyers get the upside or downside of the asset price, not the on-chain yield.
That trade-off can look acceptable in a low-rate environment. It looks different when Treasuries pay coupons and money-market funds offer yield. In that setting, a product that only delivers price exposure carries a clearer opportunity cost. ETHA is also the largest and most convenient entry point for institutions, so reducing ETH exposure may naturally start there.
The article does not treat that explanation as complete. Grayscale's ETHE has long offered staking and still posted outflows in October. But it also notes ETHE's 2.5% management fee and its own historical baggage, which make a direct comparison difficult. The more cautious conclusion is that macro conditions are the wind, while product structure determines where the leaks show up first.
BlackRock's answer was ETHB
BlackRock has already launched a second Ether product aimed at that gap. On March 12, 2026, the iShares Staked Ethereum Trust, trading under the ticker ETHB, listed on Nasdaq.
According to the prospectus cited in the article, the fund stakes 70% to 95% of its ETH. Of the staking rewards, 82% goes to shareholders, while the remaining 18% is split among the issuer, custodian Coinbase and the validator service provider. The management fee is 0.25%, reduced to 0.12% for the first 12 months on the first $2.5 billion in assets. The fund launched with about $107 million in assets.
The article also notes that ETHB was not first to market. REX-Osprey launched a similar product in September 2025, and Grayscale moved earlier than BlackRock as well, making BlackRock the third entrant.
Even then, the economics are not straightforward. A research blog cited in the article estimated staking yields at roughly 3% annualized using network data from early 2026. After the 18% split, shareholders would receive about 2.5%. The same material put the 10-year Treasury yield at about 4.2%.
That means ETHB addresses one weakness, but does not erase the yield gap with Treasuries. The prospectus also says validator exits and withdrawals require queueing, and a full scan can take as long as seven to 10 days. Part of the yield, in other words, is compensation for reduced liquidity.
For that reason, the article says it is too early to assume money leaving ETHA simply rotated into ETHB. ETHB itself also saw outflows in October. The data supports a narrower point: two Ether products from the same issuer can behave differently.
That leads back to Ether's valuation problem
From ETF flows, the article moves to a larger question: what gives ETH value in the first place? Unlike a stock, ETH has no board and no income statement, so its valuation does not fit a standard discounted cash flow framework.
It cites the 2021 paper Tokenomics: Dynamic Adoption and Valuation, published in The Review of Financial Studies by Lin William Cong, Ye Li and Neng Wang. The paper argues that token value comes from aggregate user demand for transactions rather than discounted future cash flows. More users raise token value, and higher token value can pull in more users earlier, creating a reinforcing loop.
But the article says that framework depends on users needing to hold the token in order to transact on the platform. When that assumption is compared with Ethereum's current ledger economics, a tension appears.
Lower burn after Dencun and the return of net issuance
After EIP-1559, Ethereum began burning the base fee, and heavier network use meant more ETH was destroyed. That helped build the asset's deflationary reputation. In 2024, the Dencun upgrade introduced blobs, sharply lowering the cost of posting L2 data and reducing burn on L1.
Citing CMCC research, the article says Ethereum's quarterly fee burn fell from about $1.1 billion in the first quarter of 2024 to about $300 million in the third quarter, a 73% drop. By April 2026, one media tally put daily issuance at about 1,700 ETH while only 50 to 60 ETH was being burned each day. Everstake estimated annualized net issuance at about 0.7% to 0.8% in May.
The article adds that the Fusaka upgrade in December of last year set a fee floor for blobs in an effort to lift burn, though the effect still needs time to be assessed.
With less ETH being burned and issuance continuing, the newly created ETH goes to stakers. The article frames that as protocol-level money creation used to pay those securing the network, rather than revenue paid in by outside customers.
What staking changes for holders
The article then cites the NBER working paper The Tokenomics of Staking by Lin William Cong, Zhiheng He and Ke Tang. That paper places staking into a dynamic model, argues that staking creates wealth redistribution, and finds in a sample of stakeable tokens that higher staking rates are associated with higher subsequent excess returns.
It also qualifies the paper's weight. The study is a working paper from April 2025, not a peer-reviewed journal article, and it examines a basket of stakeable tokens rather than Ethereum alone. An earlier version presented at an academic conference in 2023 was questioned on whether the carry-style returns it identified were simply compensation for higher beta to the broader crypto market. The article treats it as a useful lens, not a settled conclusion.
Applied to ETH, the article's own reasoning is that staking rewards come from new issuance. Holders who do not stake keep the same number of ETH, but their share of total supply slips slightly over time. Net issuance below 1% a year is not huge in absolute terms, yet the more important distinction is whether an investor receives the rewards at all. ETHA holders do not.
That is why the article argues that a busier network does not automatically make the token scarcer. Network security depends on staking, staking rewards depend on issuance, and the final burden of that issuance depends on how much burn offsets it in a given period.
Ethereum can grow as infrastructure without ETH capturing all the value
The article cites a Blockworks analysis describing a similar mismatch. User activity is rising, stablecoin usage is strong, and rollups are pushing blob data to record levels, yet Ethereum L1 fee revenue remains far below 2021 and 2022. Value capture has shifted upward to L2 sequencers, the MEV supply chain and applications, leaving L1 as a reliable but low-margin settlement layer.
Coin Metrics data cited in the piece puts blob fees at just 0.07% of total fees in the first quarter of 2025.
Its analogy is a highway that lowers tolls to attract more traffic. More cars use the road, but the money is made by service stations, gas stops and roadside businesses, while the toll booth mainly watches the flow go by. The road becomes more important. That does not mean the toll booth captures more value.
The article says stablecoin settlement, tokenized cash and institution-issued real-world assets are all moving onto Ethereum. It cites a 2026 outlook from 21Shares acknowledging that trend while also arguing that fee compression, value leakage to L2 and mild net issuance raise the bar for turning throughput into durable value. In that framing, ETH would need either higher total fees, better alignment between L2 and the base layer, or a shift in flows and yield differentials to be repriced.
Institutions may want Ethereum without wanting ETH as a position
The article pushes the point further. Traditional financial institutions issuing tokenized Treasuries or settling with stablecoins may want Ethereum's settlement and security, but that does not mean they want ETH on the balance sheet as an investment position.
Buying some ETH to pay gas is closer to an operating expense than a portfolio allocation. Needing the infrastructure and wanting to hold the asset are two different propositions. How wide that gap is remains contested.
It cites an Everstake review from May saying the debate includes several camps: some argue for changing the reward curve, some favor the status quo, and some say the real issue is L1 value capture. The review itself leans toward the last view.
Three paths to watch after October's outflows
The article ends by saying October's data alone cannot answer whether institutions are abandoning Ethereum. The narrower inference is that what may be getting sold is not ETH itself, but a way of holding ETH that pays no yield and does not guarantee access to the network's economic upside. It presents that as an inference, not a conclusion.
From there, it lays out three paths to watch.
- Macro recovery. If rates fall and risk appetite returns, ETF flows could come back. The sequence matters: flows returning before price would suggest early positioning, while flows arriving after a rally would look more like momentum chasing.
- Product replacement. The next question is whether staked products can keep attracting capital and whether ETHA could eventually change its structure to include staking. The article notes that ETHB's net yield still trails Treasuries, so its appeal is tied to the rate backdrop.
- Weaker value capture. If Bitcoin ETF flows recover while Ether ETF flows do not, if the ETH/BTC ratio keeps falling, if net issuance stays positive and blob revenue does not improve, the problem would look more specific to ETH rather than just macro conditions.
On the network side, the article notes that a mainnet date for the Glamsterdam upgrade has not been set. It also says the Hoodi testnet upgrade was delayed on Oct. 22, according to an Ethereum Foundation announcement. The article does not claim those events caused the redemptions, but says they may have reduced patience among investors waiting for the next catalyst.
That brings the discussion back to the original number. The visible part is the $1.607 billion that left US spot Ether ETFs in October. The harder question sits outside the ledger of fund flows: as Ethereum's infrastructure role expands, how much of that economic value can ETH itself keep?


