Why Crypto Still Needs Options Even After Perpetual Futures Took Off

Why Crypto Still Needs Options Even After Perpetual Futures Took Off

N
News Editor
2026-10-23 12:38:00
A PANews feature argues that perpetual futures may dominate crypto trading today, but they still fail at one thing options are built to handle: time. A trader can be right on Bitcoin’s direction over three months and still get liquidated tomorrow in a leveraged perpetual position. Options, by contrast, let that view survive short-term volatility, even if the premium can still go to zero by expiry. Using BTC data from January 2018 to October 2026, the article estimates that even among trades where the direction was ultimately correct, a 10x perpetual long would have faced a 47% liquidation probability over a 180-day holding period, 29% over 90 days, and 18% over 60 days. The piece also reviews a three-position BTC case study from Oct. 10, 2025 and compares the outcomes of a perpetual long, a call option, and a perpetual long protected by a put. The article says on-chain options have stayed small because of three structural problems: fragmented order books, expensive hedging for sellers, and heavy capital requirements. It argues that newer venues built around perpetual infrastructure, especially platforms with unified margin systems and deep hedging markets, may finally change that. Hyperliquid is framed as the “landlord” of the hedge market, Derive as a possible options backend, and Paradex as a block-trading venue. The piece also explores two supply-side ideas: embedding options into Metric-style liquidity pools and adapting Papertrade’s token-incentive model for options vaults.

Perpetual futures are already one of crypto’s most mature products. The PANews article asks a harder question: if perps are this developed, why does the market still need options?

Why Crypto Still Needs Options Even After Perpetual Futures Took Off 2

Its answer is simple: time.

A trader may be right that Bitcoin will rise over the next three months. In a leveraged perpetual position, that trade can still be liquidated the next day. A call option gives that view more room to play out. The buyer can still lose the full premium, but a single violent move does not automatically force the position out.

That framing leads into the article’s main investigation: why on-chain options remain so small, even after years of experimentation. The author says the issue comes down in large part to one question — whether selling options is worth doing at all. Perpetual venues may be able to change that because they can give options sellers a hedge and reuse an existing base of active traders.

Papertrade as a starting point for an options incentive model

The article says the author spent the past few weeks using Papertrade, a platform that takes the other side of every trade. For every $1 a trader loses, the platform mints an equal amount of PAPER tokens. Holders of that token share in the platform’s fee revenue.

That “losses mint tokens, tokens share fees” structure led to a broader thought experiment: what would happen if the same logic were applied to options, a sector that still has not produced a breakout on-chain product.

The piece argues that perpetuals let traders define how much adverse price movement they can tolerate, but they do not tolerate being wrong on timing for very long. Options do.

The author notes that in July 2025, the team had already argued that on-chain options would grow alongside perpetuals and could see trading volume rise 100x within three years. Fifteen months later, on-chain options volume still sits below 1% of decentralized perpetual volume. In traditional finance, by contrast, options volume is roughly three times futures volume.

From there, the article sets out to quantify the cost paid by traders who get direction right but enter too early, explain why the next generation of on-chain options is likely to be built on perpetual infrastructure such as Hyperliquid, map out the paths taken by different projects, and identify who stands to benefit if volume expands. Its short conclusion is direct: the side that controls hedging will win the most.

The names it highlights are Hyperliquid as the “landlord” of the hedge market, Derive as the options engine, and Paradex as the block-trading desk. It also sketches two ways to close the seller supply gap: embedding options into Metric liquidity pools and building an options version of Papertrade.

Being right on direction still does not save a perp trade

The article uses Bitcoin daily closing prices from January 2018 to October 2026 and treats every day as a potential long entry. It keeps only the cases where the closing price 7 to 180 days later was above the entry price, meaning the trader’s directional view was correct. It then measures whether the drawdown during the holding period would have been enough to liquidate 5x, 10x, or 20x leveraged perpetual positions.

Why Crypto Still Needs Options Even After Perpetual Futures Took Off 3

The results are stark. For BTC longs that were directionally correct, a 10x perpetual had a 47% liquidation probability over a 180-day holding period, 29% over 90 days, and 18% over 60 days. The article adds that the calculation uses only daily closes and does not include intraday wick events, so real liquidation odds would be higher. An option bought over the same window would not be forcibly closed before expiry.

The author says a previous article published in March had already argued that short-term trading had almost entirely migrated to perpetuals. That still holds in hourly trading. But the longer a thesis needs to play out, the more likely a perp position is to hit a stop or liquidation.

A three-position BTC test from Oct. 10, 2025

The article revisits market action on Oct. 10, 2025. At 12:00 UTC, it opens three BTC long positions, each with $1,000 in capital:

  • a 10x perpetual long,
  • a 30-day call option purchased with the full $1,000,
  • and a 10x perpetual long paired with a 7-day put option struck 5% below the entry price, with the put premium deducted from the same $1,000 principal.

The outcomes diverged sharply. The perpetual position was liquidated at 21:14 UTC. The call option fell as low as $181, then rebounded above $800 within an hour. The protective put, which cost $52, allowed the 10x long to survive the selloff.

The author says the same test was repeated across eight assets using Deribit quotes and produced the same pattern. On altcoins, though, the protection becomes much more expensive. The article says equivalent downside protection costs $250 to $340 of principal because altcoin options already price in a very large volatility premium.

More tradable assets create more demand for options

The article describes the convergence between traditional finance and crypto across three dimensions.

Traditional finance is adopting crypto market tools

It says CME now supports around-the-clock trading in crypto futures and options. Hyperliquid perpetual market data has been integrated into Bloomberg terminals. Hyperliquid’s policy team and Trade.xyz are applying to the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission for rules covering pre-IPO perpetuals. Polymarket, the article adds, launched perpetuals for users outside the United States in September.

Crypto venues are listing traditional assets

On Hyperliquid, users can trade perpetuals tied to the S&P 500, Nvidia, gold, and crude oil around the clock. The author repeats an earlier view that assets such as government bonds, equities, compute power, and attention can all move on-chain, with perpetuals acting as the trading wrapper.

One example in the article is Trade.xyz’s WTI and Brent crude perpetuals, which reached $2.3 billion in daily volume on March 23. It also points to newer markets such as hourly rental-rate perpetuals on Nvidia H100 GPUs and perpetuals tied to a Pokemon card index. CME and ICE are said to be waiting for Commodity Futures Trading Commission approval to list compute-power futures.

The broader point is that as the menu of tradable assets expands, demand for more varied trading tools rises with it. Someone may trade GPU perpetuals to bet on a shortage in compute. An AI company may want to hedge the risk of higher compute rental costs. In that case, the company can pay a fixed premium for an option: if rental rates rise above the agreed level, the option pays the difference; if rates fall, the company benefits from cheaper compute and loses only the premium. The article’s conclusion is that every new perpetual market can give rise to a matching options market.

Why Crypto Still Needs Options Even After Perpetual Futures Took Off 4

Traditional finance tools are being used for crypto-native assets

The article says BlackRock’s Bitcoin ETF options reached $27.6 billion in notional open interest in April, overtaking Deribit’s Bitcoin options. It also notes Coinbase’s $2.9 billion acquisition of Deribit.

From there, the author argues that a single venue could eventually offer spot, perpetuals, options, and binaries across Bitcoin, equities, and commodities. The first platform to put that full stack together could capture most of the flow. Crypto has two built-in advantages here: listing new markets is a software decision, and trading runs 24/7.

The article contrasts IBIT, which launched in January 2024 but did not get listed options until November that year after exchange, clearinghouse, and SEC approvals, with Hypercall, which listed SpaceX options on 2026-06-03, nine days before SpaceX’s Nasdaq listing, using pre-IPO perpetuals as the price reference. Hypercall also supports Sunday trading in Nvidia and SpaceX options. Bid-ask spreads widen by 1.5x to 2x outside U.S. equity hours, the article says, but traditional venues do not offer options trading in those windows at all.

Why on-chain options kept failing

Since 2019, dozens of protocols have tried to build on-chain options. Most shut down, pivoted, or faded to near-zero volume. The article says options are harder to make work than perpetuals for three reasons.

  1. Order books fragment badly. A BTC perpetual needs one order book. On Deribit alone, BTC has 11 expiries and 884 option contracts, all of which need continuous quotes.
  2. Sellers struggle to hedge cheaply. They need to trade the underlying continuously to stay delta-neutral, which requires a deep surrounding market.
  3. Short options consume too much capital. Early protocols required sellers to post collateral equal to the maximum possible loss. The article gives an example of a BTC call with a $110,000 strike: the seller earns only $1,800 in premium but must lock up $100,000 in collateral, a monthly return of just 1.8%.

One generation of protocols solved one problem and then failed on another. The article cites Hegic depositors losing about $80 million in principal in May 2021, Lyra’s early version posting a 4.9% loss in its BTC pool and a 17.6% loss in its ETH pool within seven months of launch, and PsyOptions shutting down in June 2024.

It also explains why market makers avoid new venues. Before retail flow arrives, most quote requests come from arbitrageurs trading against Deribit and other platforms. They only hit quotes when the new venue is mispriced, which means market makers lose on most fills. A platform then has only two choices: subsidize those losses or find retail order flow that would not otherwise exist.

What changed: unified accounts, portfolio margin, and perp hedging

The article says the platforms that are working today look broadly similar in structure. Matching happens off-chain. Collateral custody, margin, liquidation, and settlement happen on-chain, while users keep control of their assets.

But architecture alone is not enough. Sellers need strong incentives, and the strongest one is the ability to hedge cheaply in the same account.

The article returns to the earlier BTC call example. Selling the option requires $100,000 in collateral under a full-margin model. With a portfolio margin engine, margin is calculated against the maximum potential risk across the whole book. If a reasonable maximum move is set at 15%, the seller needs to post only about $15,000 while still collecting the same $1,800 premium. That lifts the monthly return on posted capital from 1.8% to about 12%.

That is why, in the author’s view, options activity will break out where perpetual liquidity already exists, with Hyperliquid and Lighter named as examples. Hyperliquid gives options sellers three things that are hard to find together elsewhere:

Why Crypto Still Needs Options Even After Perpetual Futures Took Off 5

  • the deepest on-chain perpetual order books and an open developer API,
  • a unified account system where collateral posted for a short put can be reused in a long perpetual position,
  • and control over both liquidity and distribution.

Hypercall is presented as the first options platform built on that stack. A market maker selling Nvidia calls can buy Nvidia perpetuals in the same account to hedge, and that hedge directly lowers the margin required for the options position. Hypercall’s founder estimates that perpetual market makers outnumber options market makers by 10x to 100x. The platform’s goal is to convert that perp-making base into options liquidity.

How Derive, Paradex, and Rysk are sourcing sellers

The article outlines three different approaches.

Derive, formerly Lyra, subsidizes sellers directly. Over the year through Oct. 19, it handled about $18 billion in notional cleared volume. Its only publicly disclosed market-making partner is FalconX. FalconX keeps funds with its own custodian, while Derive mirrors those balances on-chain so the institution can quote without moving capital on-chain.

Paradex brings in external sellers. After connecting to the Paradigm network on Sept. 15 — a network that handles one-quarter of Deribit’s block trades — its daily options volume jumped from under $3 million to $58.7 million within a week. By Oct. 14, though, open interest had fallen from $250 million to $96 million. The article says block traders tend to leave after the trade and do not build lasting open interest.

Rysk tries to turn ordinary token holders into sellers. Users deposit HYPE, BTC, or ETH and sell covered calls to whitelisted market makers, receiving premium immediately. In the 30 days through Oct. 14, notional volume reached $148 million. The article says volume stalls once the HYPE exposure limit on the call-buying side is reached.

Front-end products can hide the complexity of strike grids. Dream supports Apple Pay deposits and lets users choose only direction and size while the platform buys the option. Tacticalls, built on Derive, offers a three-step order flow and copy trading. Still, the article’s point is blunt: a good front end can attract users, but it cannot create liquidity if the underlying order book has no sellers.

Volume is growing, but liquidity is uneven

September 2026 was the best month in the history of on-chain options, according to the article. Notional volume nearly doubled to $5 billion. Premium volume rose by one-third to $85 million. Open interest peaked near $2.5 billion. Even so, that was only 7% of Deribit’s monthly volume, and most of the activity happened on Derive.

The article warns that notional volume can be inflated by listing large numbers of cheap, far out-of-the-money contracts. Premium paid — actual cash changing hands — is the cleaner metric. On that basis, Derive’s market share is above 90%.

Hypercall’s notional volume, the article says, mostly comes from short-dated, deep out-of-the-money S&P 500 options that trade more like lottery tickets. Pink Brains estimates that each $1 of premium on Hypercall can represent about $1,000 of notional exposure, while on Derive $1 of premium corresponds to about $50 of notional. The article attributes that gap to three factors:

  • S&P 500 annualized volatility is about 16%, versus 43% for BTC, making index options cheaper.
  • Short-dated, deep out-of-the-money calls naturally carry very low premium as a share of notional.
  • During Hypercall’s period of distributing $1,000 in HYPE rewards per day, notional volume rose 50x while premium barely moved, suggesting traders were buying the cheapest contracts mainly to farm rewards.

The article says traders who actually want options exposure are still using Derive.

Why Crypto Still Needs Options Even After Perpetual Futures Took Off 6

It then compares order-book quality on Derive and Deribit using BTC and ETH options listed on both venues as of the evening of Oct. 19, excluding deep out-of-the-money contracts and those expiring within three days. Deribit had two-sided quotes on all 346 strikes. Derive had two-sided markets on only 206 strikes. For contracts that did have quotes, Derive’s ask prices were within 0.2% of Deribit’s, and its bid-ask spread was 3.8% of option price versus 2.6% on Deribit. The article notes that in July 2025, according to “Trading Optionality,” Derive’s spreads were 2x to 5x wider than Deribit’s, so the gap has narrowed.

Outside BTC and ETH, the picture changes. Derive lists options on 12 assets. Looking at all strikes expiring on Dec. 25, the article says HYPE, BTC, and ETH still show some offers, but LIT and the smaller altcoins behind it have almost none. Across PUMP, LIT, ADA, VVV, and CC, there was only one ask quote across 220 strikes. The author says an attempt to buy a December PUMP call took a long time to fill. Even when quotes exist, spreads widen quickly once the strike moves away from spot. The same pattern appeared across other platforms. Aevo’s MEME options can only trade through an OTC desk, and Dream moved PUMP and LIT trading to a single OTC counterparty.

The article’s conclusion here is straightforward: listing an options contract is almost free, but making markets and selling options is expensive and risky.

How large can the market get?

The article compares traditional and on-chain derivatives directly. In 2025, traditional markets traded 88.65 billion options contracts and 30.64 billion futures contracts. In the 30 days through 2026-10-19, on-chain options traded $4.9 billion in notional volume, while decentralized perpetuals traded $627 billion. Options were only about 0.8% of perp volume.

The author argues that many products are options in all but name. A mortgage with prepayment rights resembles a call option bought from a bank. Insurance is effectively a put option. Employee equity compensation is a call option paid as wages. Those same needs exist in crypto.

Still, the article does not expect on-chain options to reach the same options-to-futures ratio seen in traditional finance. Binary contracts, prediction markets, and native binary products will absorb part of the demand. Lighter launched BTC and ETH binary options on Oct. 19.

Even with that caveat, the article identifies three durable sources of demand:

  • assets traditional finance cannot list quickly, such as HYPE, pre-IPO names, GPU compute rental, and weekend trading in stocks and oil,
  • users traditional finance does not reach, including non-U.S. users, people without brokerage accounts, and retail traders who want to participate with as little as $1, with India’s retail options culture cited as an example and NSE weekly options accounting for 95% of total volume,
  • and options functionality embedded inside other products, such as downside protection attached to perpetuals, covered calls on government bonds, liquidation insurance in lending, and API-based options rails inside any dApp.

Old winners in a new market

The article says the fee path of a single options trade reveals the market structure. The options venue collects a small execution fee. The seller, however, generates repeated fees for the perpetual venue every time the hedge is adjusted. That is why options trading can drive perp volume. Deribit, the article notes, has more than $2 billion in futures open interest, used mainly to hedge options positions on the platform.

It breaks the market into three core roles:

  • Hyperliquid as the landlord of the hedge market. It controls the hedge venue, the margin account, and the user base. HIP-4 binary contracts share the same account framework as options. The article says HIP-4 is itself option-like and may even divert business from Hypercall, but the hedge volume stays on Hyperliquid either way.
  • Derive as the options engine. It has order-book depth, a risk engine, institutional users, and an open V3 API. If wallets, vaults, and AI agents route options orders there, Derive could become the backend for on-chain options. If not, it remains a venue supported by subsidies and a small number of market makers.
  • Paradex as the block desk. Its connection to Paradigm gives it value in large trades, and institutional market makers can also improve the order book for ordinary users.

Platforms that cannot offer sellers a hedge are losing ground, the article says. Even as the sector grew fourfold, Aevo’s options business shrank by more than 90%. A standalone options product struggles against one that can be combined with spot and perpetuals. The likely end state, in the author’s view, is one where base-layer platforms host liquidity and many front ends plug into them, similar to the Builder Code model in DeFi today.

Why Crypto Still Needs Options Even After Perpetual Futures Took Off 7

The market has already started pricing that possibility. The article says Citrini Research’s “Breaking The Wall” portfolio allocates 10% to DRV. DRV is up more than 1,000% this year. As of Oct. 22, its market capitalization stood at $390 million, with net revenue of $486,000 over the past 30 days, implying a 66x annualized revenue multiple.

The article then runs a growth scenario for Derive. If on-chain options volume reaches 5% of perpetual volume, and October perpetual volume comes in at $660 billion, options notional would be $33 billion. If Derive keeps an 80% market share and charges 1.1 basis points in fees, annualized fee revenue would be $35 million. Relative to the current market cap, the article says that implies 11x upside in revenue. At the same time, DRV’s current price already assumes the sector grows sixfold, Derive keeps its share, and it still competes with Hyperliquid, Lighter, and Paradex.

Two ideas to expand seller supply

Embedding options into Metric liquidity pools

The article says options sellers do not all have to come from dedicated options venues. Metric is a DEX with active liquidity pools that resemble Uniswap concentrated liquidity, except the price bands shift automatically with oracle prices instead of requiring LPs to reset them manually. In the 30 days through Oct. 21, Metric had about $12 million in deposits and $4.4 billion in total volume.

The author asks what happens if those pools quote options directly. Metric’s documentation mentions Black-Scholes, with volatility as an input, as a candidate oracle pricing model. A pool manager could use real-time volatility to price tokenized ETH calls.

The article gives a concrete example. With ETH around $2,430 and implied volatility at 50%, a call expiring on Oct. 30 with a $2,600 strike would be priced at $18 under Black-Scholes. If ETH rises to $2,500, the option’s value would move to $35, and the liquidity bands would all shift upward. Metric pools connect to aggregators including 0x, 1inch, CoW Swap, and PancakeSwap, so users could buy option tokens the same way they swap ordinary tokens.

The drawback is poor capital efficiency. Every strike and every expiry needs its own token and its own pool. For the same $2,600 ETH call, a Deribit market maker can quote hundreds of contracts in one margin account. On Derive, selling that call requires only about $330 in margin before hedging. On Metric, if the seller uses a fully collateralized model, one full ETH worth $2,430 must be locked to earn an $18 premium. Five strikes across two expiries would require 10 separate pools with no shared capital.

The article’s proposed improvement is to let Derive issue the option tokens. Derive already supports seller margin and perpetual hedging, so selling the call would still require only $330 in posted collateral. Metric would handle pricing and user distribution.

An options version of Papertrade

The article then returns to the Papertrade concept. Token incentives can attract capital and traders quickly, it says, and that is exactly what on-chain options sellers currently lack.

In the proposed options version, a vault acts as the counterparty and sells calls and puts. If an option expires worthless, the platform mints tokens in proportion to the premium lost by the buyer. Users who stake the token share in the vault’s surplus.

The article says options buyers lose most of the time. A backtest from January 2018 to October 2026 shows that weekly BTC calls struck 10% above spot expire with a total loss of premium in 87% of weeks. That makes the Papertrade framework a natural fit for this kind of product. But unlike high-leverage perpetuals, where small moves can trigger liquidation, options buyers hold to expiry. The vault cannot rely on liquidations for profit. Premium pricing has to be fair.

Why Crypto Still Needs Options Even After Perpetual Futures Took Off 8

The risk is obvious. A short-options vault may earn small profits in most months, then face a very large payout in a one-way market. The article runs a cold-start simulation using BTC history. Starting from zero, the vault continuously sells weekly calls struck 10% above spot. For every $100,000 in BTC notional, it collects an average premium of $1,300, which is 50% above theoretical fair value. In 57 out of 458 weeks, or 12% of the sample, BTC closed above the strike, with an average payout of $6,900. Across all trades, the vault collected $1,300, paid out $860, and netted $440 on average.

Over an eight-year period, the vault is profitable overall. But in the extreme market of March 2021, the article says the required payout equaled 30 weeks of premium income, and the payout queue was not fully cleared until April 2022. The largest single-week payout equaled 20 weeks of premium revenue.

That means the product design has to solve the payout-queue problem. Users who share in surplus during calm periods also need to absorb losses in extreme markets so profitable users can redeem immediately. The vault also needs dynamic hedging in an external perpetual market. As BTC approaches the strike, it would buy BTC perpetuals on Hyperliquid to hedge.

Once daily hedging is added to the simulation, the worst one-week payout burden falls from 20 weeks of income to 10 weeks, and the vault no longer goes into debt during the 2021 rally. The article says a prediction-market piece titled “parlays piece” reached the same conclusion: liquidity has to be managed by a centralized entity.

A second improvement would let the vault both buy and sell options from users instead of only taking the other side. When long and short positions match, the vault carries no exposure and earns only the spread. It would manage risk only on the residual net position.

The article also points to a flaw in the token design. If tokens are minted whenever either side loses, a user can open two accounts, buy and sell the same option, guarantee a loss on one side, and farm tokens. The proposed fix is to mint tokens based on net losses per account and per expiry, while keeping the bid-ask spread wider than the token-arbitrage value, following logic similar to Papertrade’s current design.

Stronger infrastructure, but one open question remains

The article ends on a measured note. It says this cycle of on-chain options experimentation has a better chance than earlier ones because sellers can now hedge in deeper markets, use capital more efficiently, and reach buyers through more channels. Incentives can also help with cold starts.

Still, one question is unresolved. Once rewards shrink and market conditions turn, will sellers earn enough to keep quoting?

The author does not claim that answer is already known. What the article does say is that the infrastructure under this cycle is much stronger than in previous attempts. If it holds, more traders will be able to price the time cost of their market view — the waiting period required for a thesis to play out. Crypto already made leverage easy to trade. Time, the article argues, may be the next thing the market learns to trade.

This article was originally published by Bit.Fan. For more cryptocurrency news and market insights, visit www.bit.fan.
7900

Disclaimer:

The market information, project data, and third-party content displayed on this platform are for industry information sharing only and do not constitute any form of investment advice or return commitment.

Cryptocurrency trading carries high risks. Users should fully assess their risk tolerance and make independent decisions. All profits, losses, and legal responsibilities are borne by the users themselves.