Researchers say HBF economics and manufacturing outlook remain unproven
Researchers from P Equity Research and SemiAnalysis, including Nick Doyle, discussed high-bandwidth flash, or HBF, in an X Space, outlining where the technology may fit and where major uncertainties remain. Doyle said it is still too early to judge how much HBF can narrow its cost premium versus high-bandwidth memory, or HBM, because much of the current information comes from vendor claims. He cited Sandisk’s estimate that cost per bit could be about one-eighth that of HBM, while cautioning that structural costs tied to TSVs, stacking, and pSLC mode would not disappear even if yield and testing improve with scale. Endurance remains a central unknown, he said, because higher-than-expected wear would raise overall costs. The discussion also framed HBF as a narrow-use product rather than a replacement for HBM, aimed at AI inference workloads such as low-batch, long-context mixture-of-experts models. Its target bandwidth of about 1.6 TB/s, around HBM3E class, may suit sequential reads for loading model weights and smaller local or private enterprise GPU setups. Thermal reliability and mass production were also flagged as open questions, while NAND shortages are expected to last through 2028.








