Why a MarsBit essay argues S&OP can intensify, not resolve, KPI conflicts
MarsBit has published a long-form commentary by GritMeng that uses a stripped-down manufacturing example — two demand orders and three materials — to argue that traditional sales and operations planning, or S&OP, does not remove KPI conflicts inside factories built on shared materials, shared capacity and bottleneck constraints. The article says the usual fix of putting sales, production, procurement and finance in the same room can make matters worse if planning logic still lets high-priority orders lock up early shared resources even when those orders cannot be completed until later. The piece builds its case around a simple setup: one shared material A, one dedicated material B, one bottleneck material C, and two orders with different due dates and priorities. Under a static priority-first scheduling rule, the higher-priority order grabs the only available unit of A even though it cannot start until C arrives later, while the lower-priority order that could have shipped earlier is forced into delay. GritMeng calls this an "X-shaped cross mismatch" and uses it to explain inventory buildup, shortages, idle capacity, late delivery and cross-department KPI clashes. The article then proposes a different planning approach that separates business priority from the real completion window, and cites operating data from Lenovo’s global integrated planning system as well as a 296-second stress test for an IPC planning engine on a laptop-scale setup.




