token buybacksOct 7, 2026
Why heavy token buybacks may not actually benefit holders
A MarsBit opinion piece by Danny argues that crypto protocols sending most of their revenue into token buybacks and burns are not automatically creating long-term value for holders. The article uses Bed Bath & Beyond’s collapse as a corporate analogy: a company can keep repurchasing equity while weakening its ability to fund operations, reinvest, and withstand stress. From there, it applies the same lens to crypto, asking whether protocols that devote 80%, 90%, or even all fee income to buybacks are sacrificing product development, security reserves, distribution, and ecosystem growth for a cleaner secondary-market narrative.
The piece compares several protocols and mechanisms, including PONS, Pump.fun, Raydium, PancakeSwap, dYdX, Aave, and Aster. It argues that headline buyback ratios can be misleading because fee flows, treasury assets, foundation funds, and operating cash may sit in different entities, while bought-back tokens may be burned, held, or redistributed rather than permanently removed from circulation. It also stresses that crypto revenue is highly cyclical, making aggressive buyback commitments fragile when income drops or security incidents hit.
Danny’s conclusion is not that buybacks are always bad. Instead, he argues they make sense only after a protocol has durable competitive advantages, limited reinvestment needs, and enough reserves. Otherwise, early buybacks may improve token marketing and exit liquidity more than they improve the business itself.