Kalshi Senate contracts show pricing gaps as one election question trades at four different probabilities

Kalshi Senate contracts show pricing gaps as one election question trades at four different probabilities

N
News Editor
2026-10-29 04:51:25
A Coin Metrics research note examining Kalshi’s 2026 U.S. midterm election markets found that contracts tied to the same Senate control outcome were not priced consistently across the platform. Using 38 Senate-related contracts, the study showed that four contract families implied different probabilities for whether Democrats would control the Senate, with an average spread of 3.3 percentage points since August and a peak intraday gap of 9.7 points. As of Oct. 25, implied probabilities still ranged from 62.5% to 65.3%. The report also modeled a theoretical nine-leg arbitrage package: buying the Democratic Senate control contract and buying NO on each Democratic seat-count contract from 51 seats through 57 or more. If both contract families settle on the same underlying fact pattern, the package returns a fixed $8 regardless of the election outcome. Based on end-of-day prices, the total cost fell below $8 on 19 of 51 trading days, creating theoretical arbitrage windows. That edge narrowed sharply once execution assumptions were added. Estimated fees averaged 5.2 cents per package, and thin liquidity in several seat-count contracts made real-world execution difficult. Under aggressive taker execution across all nine legs, only two trading days remained profitable after fees. The study argues that fragmented order books, uneven liquidity, legging risk, settlement timing differences and capital lock-up help explain why these pricing gaps can persist even in a fast-growing prediction market.

Prediction markets tied to the 2026 U.S. midterm elections have grown into a large trading venue, but a Coin Metrics research report argues that the headline probability most people quote captures only a small part of what is actually happening inside the market.

Kalshi Senate contracts show pricing gaps as one election question trades at four different probabilities 2

Using Kalshi’s Senate control markets as a case study, the firm tracked 38 separate contracts linked to the same broad question: whether Democrats will control the Senate. The result was a market structure in which one binary political outcome produced four different implied answers, depending on which contract family was used to infer the probability.

One election outcome, 38 contracts

According to the report, cumulative trading volume tied to the 2026 midterms on Kalshi and Polymarket had already passed $1.4 billion with one week left before the election. Public discussion usually centers on a single number, such as Kalshi showing Democrats at roughly 63% to win the Senate.

Coin Metrics said that figure sits on top of a much more fragmented structure. On Kalshi alone, Senate control exposure was spread across 38 independent contracts listed under five event groupings, each with its own order book and trading crowd.

The report grouped those contracts into four families:

  • a direct binary contract on whether Democrats control the Senate,
  • laddered contracts on the exact number of seats won by each party, covering 51 seats through 57 or more,
  • power-balance combination contracts, and
  • the inverse Republican control contract.

If all of those instruments priced the same underlying fact efficiently, their implied probabilities should line up. They did not.

Kalshi Senate contracts show pricing gaps as one election question trades at four different probabilities 3

Four curves moved in the same direction, but rarely matched

At a broad level, the four contract families told a similar macro story. The implied probability of Democratic Senate control rose from about 46% in early August to a 60% to 65% range in October.

At specific points, though, the market often disagreed with itself. Coin Metrics found that on roughly two-thirds of trading days, the implied probability derived from Democratic seat-count ladders was higher than the headline control contract. On Sept. 20, the four answers diverged sharply, ranging from 55.7%, inferred from Republican seat-count contracts, to 65.4%, inferred from Democratic seat-count contracts.

The average spread between the highest and lowest implied probabilities was 3.3 percentage points. The gap was widest in September, averaging 4.5 points, versus 3.2 points in August. Even in October, when trading activity was stronger, the average spread still held at 2.5 points. On Oct. 21, the maximum valuation gap across the four contract families was still 4.0 points.

In other words, more trading did not automatically force the prices into alignment.

The nine-leg package

The report then built a theoretical arbitrage structure. When two sets of contracts that should be economically equivalent disagree on the same election fact, a trader can in theory buy the cheaper side of each and lock in a deterministic payoff.

Kalshi Senate contracts show pricing gaps as one election question trades at four different probabilities 4

In this case, the structure was a nine-leg package:

  1. Buy YES on the contract for Democrats to win Senate control. If Democrats win control, that leg pays $1.
  2. Buy NO on each Democratic exact seat-count contract from 51 seats through 57 seats and 57 or more. Each of those legs pays $1 as long as the final result does not land exactly in that bucket.

If the control contract family and the seat-count family settle on the same factual basis, the package returns a fixed $8 at expiry under any election outcome. That means any total entry cost below $8 creates a theoretical arbitrage opportunity.

Profitable in theory on 19 days, much less so after fees

Coin Metrics backtested the package using end-of-day prices from Aug. 1 through Oct. 25 and stressed that the exercise was theoretical.

Before fees, and assuming each leg was bought aggressively at the ask, the total package cost came in below $8 on 19 of 51 trading days. On Oct. 24, the gross arbitrage spread peaked at 8.1 cents per $8 package before fees.

Once estimated trading fees were included, the picture changed quickly. The report put average fees at about 5.2 cents per package. Under a fully aggressive taker assumption across all nine legs, only two trading days remained profitable after fees.

Execution assumptions mattered a great deal. If the main leg could be filled passively, simulated excess returns stayed positive on seven trading days, with a peak of +4.7 cents.

Kalshi Senate contracts show pricing gaps as one election question trades at four different probabilities 5

The report also gave a live order-book example from Oct. 25. Building 10 packages cost $79.65 including estimated fees, while the fixed payout at settlement was $80, leaving a net profit of just $0.35.

Most of the positive windows appeared in the final two weeks before the election, which the report linked to a rise in trading activity and wider pricing dislocations as the vote approached.

Why the gap persists

The report said the answer lies in market microstructure rather than in the payoff math.

Liquidity was heavily concentrated. Since August, the notional cumulative trading volume across all Kalshi Senate contracts was about $14.3 million, and more than 90% of that was absorbed by the flagship Senate control contract. The Democratic control leg alone traded $3.3 million.

Several of the seat-count contracts needed for the hedge were barely active. The Democratic 54-seat contract had cumulative volume of only $3,000, and the Democratic 56-seat contract only $2,000. In practice, the weakest leg can determine whether the whole package is tradable.

Kalshi Senate contracts show pricing gaps as one election question trades at four different probabilities 6

Four frictions cut into the trade

Legging risk

A trader only locks in the theoretical payoff after all nine orders are filled. If one thin leg slips or fails to execute, the remaining position can be left exposed to one-sided price moves.

Fee drag

Kalshi’s fee schedule is parabolic, highest around the 50-cent area and lower near 0 and 100 cents. At roughly 5.2 cents per package, fees were enough to erase most of the small gross spread.

Settlement mismatch

The strategy assumes the Senate control contract and the exact seat-count contracts settle on the same factual basis. Coin Metrics noted that the control contract settles once the election result is clear, while the seat-count contracts settle based on the formal composition of Congress on Feb. 1, 2027. A resignation, party switch or recount dispute in the interim could break the assumed $8 payoff.

Capital lock-up and opportunity cost

Most of the capital used to build the package remains tied up in seat-count contracts until Feb. 1, 2027. That multi-month holding period creates its own cost.

A broader feature of prediction markets

Coin Metrics argued that the Senate example is not an isolated anomaly. It reflects a broader structural feature of a prediction market ecosystem that is expanding quickly and becoming more fragmented.

The report said monthly prediction market trading volume rose from less than $5 billion in September 2025 to about $24 billion in April 2026. At the same time, the number of listed contracts has exploded. Based on Talos CM prediction market reference data, Kalshi had 882,762 live event contracts as of Oct. 25, 2026.

Kalshi Senate contracts show pricing gaps as one election question trades at four different probabilities 7

That fragmentation shows up in several ways. A single macro topic can be split into winner-take-all contracts, ranges, thresholds and combinations. Different venues such as Kalshi and Polymarket often list contracts on the same objective event, but with slightly different wording, fee structures and settlement rules. Liquidity is also uneven, with headline contracts attracting most of the capital while related contracts remain thin.

Those conditions create room for price dislocations, but they also make them hard to monetize.

What the report says firms need

For quantitative market makers and hedge funds, Coin Metrics said two capabilities matter most.

The first is event identification. Firms need to find contracts across platforms and contract matrices that point to the same objective outcome, normalize them to a common basis, and calculate executable prices after fees and depth. That requires a standardized event map across venues and close review of settlement language.

The second is execution. A theoretical spread on screen is not the same as realized P&L. The report said a workable approach would involve waiting passively on the most liquid main leg, then moving quickly through the eight shallow books needed for the hedge before prices drift, while controlling slippage and taker fees.

Kalshi Senate contracts show pricing gaps as one election question trades at four different probabilities 8

Methodology and references

The study used daily candlestick data from Kalshi’s public API for 38 Senate-related contracts from Aug. 1, 2026 through Oct. 25, 2026, with trading days defined in U.S. Eastern Time. All contracts included in the package had been listed on Kalshi before August 2026.

Implied probabilities were calculated from end-of-day mid-prices between the best bid and best ask. Seat-count and power-balance probabilities were normalized through ladder summation to remove excess premium caused by bid-ask spreads. Package cost used the ask for YES legs and one minus the bid for NO legs. Notional volume was defined as contracts traded multiplied by price. The contract universe came from the Talos CM prediction market reference database.

The report said all results were theoretical simulations, did not include slippage beyond quoted order-book prices, and did not constitute investment advice.

In its notes, Coin Metrics cited Talos CM API reference data showing 882,762 live Kalshi event contracts as of Oct. 25, 2026. It also cited a CNN report published on Oct. 23, 2026 saying cumulative trading volume in 2026 midterm prediction markets had passed $1.4 billion, and a Pew Research Center report published on May 27, 2026 describing a surge in recent prediction market activity.

The broader takeaway from the report is that prediction markets are not a black box that outputs one clean probability for each question. In the Kalshi Senate case, they look more like a collection of linked but separate order books. Those books generally follow the same macro narrative, yet still leave room for persistent local gaps of 2 to 3 percentage points, and sometimes more. Whether those gaps can be turned into real returns depends on data mapping, settlement analysis and execution discipline, not just on spotting the spread.

This article was originally published by Bit.Fan. For more cryptocurrency news and market insights, visit www.bit.fan.
6300

Disclaimer:

The market information, project data, and third-party content displayed on this platform are for industry information sharing only and do not constitute any form of investment advice or return commitment.

Cryptocurrency trading carries high risks. Users should fully assess their risk tolerance and make independent decisions. All profits, losses, and legal responsibilities are borne by the users themselves.