Why ICOs, VC tokens and Alpha models keep failing, and what an on-chain ICO would try to fix

Why ICOs, VC tokens and Alpha models keep failing, and what an on-chain ICO would try to fix

N
News Editor
2026-10-15 10:25:10
MarsBit has published an opinion piece by writer Qianshui Guanchaoyuan arguing that several crypto fundraising models — from early ICOs to VC-backed token launches, Alpha-style distribution and direct on-chain issuance — have broken down for the same reason: token allocation is neither fair nor transparent. The article says the current downturn is not only about prices. It reflects a broader failure in how projects raise capital, how early chips are distributed and who gets to exit first. The author walks through each phase. Early ICOs began with equal pricing but later drifted into a rebate-driven market dominated by “team leaders” and institutions. VC tokens briefly worked when fully diluted valuations were low enough to leave room for secondary buyers, but that structure deteriorated as projects started listing at multi-billion-dollar valuations while early backers still had massive embedded gains. Alpha-style models, in the author’s view, delayed VC unlocks but mostly shifted the benefit to market makers, while direct on-chain launches left regular users exposed to bots and unclear token ownership. As an alternative, the piece proposes an “on-chain ICO” framework built around real-name DID-linked addresses, equal pricing and equal unlock schedules for VCs and retail participants, plus on-chain disclosure of treasury use overseen through DAO voting. Using a hypothetical project valued at less than $10 million and raising about $4 million by selling 40% of supply, the author argues that the point is not just to put trading on-chain, but to make token ownership and movement verifiable on-chain as well.

An opinion article published by MarsBit argues that crypto’s current slump is not only a price problem. In the author’s view, the larger breakdown sits in the fundraising model itself: VC tokens struggle to find buyers, venture firms are less willing to fund new native projects, and early-stage crypto ecosystems are starting to thin out.

Written by Qianshui Guanchaoyuan, the piece says ICOs failed once, VC-backed tokens failed once, and newer formats such as Alpha-style distribution and on-chain issuance are now replaying the same pattern. The common fault line, according to the article, is unfair and opaque token distribution.

From there, the author introduces the idea of an “on-chain ICO.” The proposal is framed not as a return to 2017, but as a rebuilt ICO model that uses today’s on-chain infrastructure to turn fairness and transparency into rules that can be verified rather than promises that must be trusted.

Why earlier fundraising models broke down

ICO: equal pricing gave way to rebates and hidden costs

The article says ICOs started out with a simpler structure. During Ethereum’s ICO, institutions and retail buyers paid the same price, and no group had access to a cheaper entry.

That changed as “team leaders,” also described as proxy investors, became common. Retail users handed money to these organizers, who then invested into projects on their behalf. As the number of projects grew and lower-quality deals multiplied, project teams began offering large rebates to top organizers and institutions to attract capital.

The author says this produced three results:

  • Token costs were no longer consistent. Retail users ended up paying materially more than team leaders and institutions for the same asset.
  • The project side became opaque. Outsiders could not see how many tokens insiders held or what their actual cost basis was.
  • There were no lockups. Project teams and early buyers could sell on centralized exchanges whenever they wanted.

Under that setup, the article says, retail buyers were left holding the bag at the end, and the ICO model faded out.

VC-backed tokens: early upside existed, then disappeared

After ICOs, the market shifted its trust from team leaders to venture capital firms. The logic behind VC tokens, the author writes, was straightforward: VCs would receive early allocations and accept lockups, reducing the chance of immediate large-scale selling once a token listed.

According to the piece, this structure did work for a period. Many public-chain projects fell into the VC token category. VCs unlocked part of their allocation and were still willing to keep holding the rest, but the more important factor was valuation. Listing valuations were not excessively high, leaving room for secondary-market buyers.

The article uses Matic as its example. It says the token’s public sale price on Binance Launchpad in April 2019 was $0.00263, with a total supply of 10 billion tokens, implying a fully diluted valuation of about $26 million. On Dec. 27, 2021, it reached a high of $2.92, which translated to a fully diluted valuation of about $29 billion. The article describes that move as more than 1,000x, and says even secondary buyers still had meaningful upside in that earlier market phase.

In the author’s telling, later VC-token launches lost those characteristics for two reasons:

  • Projects started listing at very high fully diluted valuations, often in the tens of billions or even above $100 billion, leaving little or no upside for new buyers.
  • VCs still held tokens acquired at very low cost, so unlock events turned into concentrated sell pressure.

One side of the problem was a high opening valuation. The other was post-unlock dumping. The article says that combination damaged the reputation of the VC-token model and pushed it to the end of its cycle.

Alpha-style launches: a patch on VC tokens that mostly fed market makers

The article treats Binance Alpha-style models as an attempt to revise the VC-token structure. Under this arrangement, VCs are not allowed to unlock immediately and typically wait a year before vesting starts, while some of the early token advantage is redirected to retail users in the Alpha program.

On the surface, the model looks fairer. The author argues that it creates a different set of problems instead.

  • The people receiving early tokens are often not real secondary-market buyers. The article says many Alpha users are “airdrop farmers” who come for allocation rather than long-term buying.
  • VCs are locked, but when their tokens finally unlock a year later, the price is often far below the earlier highs, leaving them in a losing position whether they sell or continue to hold.
  • The only durable winners are market makers, which the author says profit by controlling price action and extracting value on the derivatives side.

The article says the result is an unhealthy market structure: there is no longer a convincing VC-token model, and genuinely new projects are not breaking out. Good projects cannot raise money inside the sector, while capital providers no longer trust the game.

Direct on-chain issuance: trading moved on-chain, ownership clarity did not

At roughly the same time as Alpha-style distribution, many VC-backed projects took another route and launched directly on-chain instead of going through exchanges. In favorable on-chain markets, the article says, this route did work for a while.

Still, the author identifies two major weaknesses.

First, the process is easy to snipe. On-chain issuance is effectively first come, first served, meaning the first buyers get the cheapest tokens. The article says script-driven traders and bots — described in the piece as “scientists” — can front-run the launch and capture early supply at very low cost, while ordinary users arrive only after the price has already become someone else’s exit level.

Second, token distribution is still opaque. The piece says the market now largely assumes that some portion of early supply is held by the project team itself. Because wallet addresses do not come with identity labels, buyers cannot tell whether a wallet selling into strength belongs to the team or to an outside holder. As a result, the higher the price goes, the harder it becomes to sustain trust.

The author sums it up this way: the market moved trading onto the chain, but not identity or token destination. Everyone can see each transaction, but not who stands behind it.

The proposed on-chain ICO model

The article says the central idea of an on-chain ICO is “absolute fairness.” The point, the author argues, is not to rely on a project team’s word but to use existing on-chain infrastructure to enforce visible rules.

It lays out three core principles.

1. Every allocation is tied to a real-name DID address

Retail buyers, VCs and exchanges would all receive tokens through addresses linked to verified DID identities. The author calls this the most important part of the framework because it would let the market distinguish project-team selling from outside selling.

Institutions could sell. Retail buyers could sell. The difference is that everyone would know who is selling, and market participants could make their own decisions with the same information set.

2. VCs and retail participants get the same price and the same unlock schedule

Under the proposal, institutions and retail buyers in the same round would purchase at the same token price and follow the same vesting timetable. The article explicitly rejects rebates, side pricing and any arrangement that allows one group to exit ahead of another.

3. Treasury use stays public on-chain and is overseen through DAO voting

The article says project teams should keep disclosing how raised funds are used on-chain, while token holders supervise spending through DAO voting and judge whether each use of funds is reasonable.

The author condenses the idea into one line: replace “trust me” with “go check it on-chain yourself.”

A sample structure: sub-$10 million valuation, roughly $4 million raised

To show how the mechanism could work, the article offers a hypothetical project structure. It suggests capping the starting valuation below $10 million and raising a few million dollars, which the author says is enough for an early-stage team to build.

The illustrative allocation is split as follows:

  • Institutional public sale: 20%, sold at the same price and with the same unlock cycle, available only to buyers using real-name DID on-chain.
  • Retail public sale: 20%, also sold at the same price and with the same unlock cycle, again requiring real-name DID on-chain.
  • Team, ecosystem and exchange liquidity: 60%, unlocked under a public plan, traceable on-chain, and obtained through real-name DID as well.

Using the sample numbers in the article, a project valued at $10 million and selling 40% of supply would raise about $4 million.

The author says the key is not just the 40% sold in the public rounds. It is whether the remaining 60% is made equally transparent.

  • For the team allocation, the chain would show whether tokens were sold after unlock.
  • For the ecosystem allocation, the market would be able to see whether tokens really reached users or were sold by the team.
  • For exchange balances and liquidity supply, the market would know in advance when tokens move or unlock, reducing the risk of surprise sell pressure.

That, in the author’s view, is what it means to use the chain properly: not just issuing tokens on-chain, but putting the destination of every token on-chain as well.

Why the author thinks this could reconnect price with fundamentals

The article argues that low starting valuations and fair fundraising preserve room for a project to grow. Many VC tokens now list at high valuations from day one, leaving no real path for price discovery based on execution.

In the on-chain ICO framework, the author says token pricing should work more like a Web2 company. If user numbers grow, ecosystem partners expand and total value locked rises, the token price should move higher and holders should have less incentive to sell. If the team fails to execute and growth slows, the price should fall. In that model, price moves are driven by fundamentals rather than by who received the cheapest early allocation.

The article compares the main fundraising models side by side:

  • Early ICOs: equal cost, untraceable token destination, no lockups, with early participants making the money.
  • ICOs in the team-leader era: unequal cost because of rebates, untraceable token destination, no lockups, with team leaders and project teams making the money.
  • VC tokens: unequal cost, untraceable token destination, VCs get in first and unlock in size, with early VCs making the money.
  • Alpha models: unequal cost, token destination only partly visible, VCs locked for one year, with market makers making the money.
  • Direct on-chain issuance: unequal cost because bot operators snipe supply, transactions visible but identities not visible, opaque unlocks, with bot operators and project teams making the money.
  • On-chain ICOs: equal cost, fully traceable token destination through real-name DID, equal unlock cycles disclosed on-chain, with projects that build real fundamentals and long-term holders making the money.

The article also stresses that the proposal defines rules, not mandatory allocation ratios. A project team could still decide how much to allocate to VCs versus retail, how to split team and ecosystem tokens, which jurisdiction to use for compliance, and how staking-based issuance would work. Participants would remain free to decide whether to join. The author’s condition is narrower: if VCs receive a larger share, the sale should still use the same price, the same unlock schedule and real-name addresses.

Not only for crypto, but potentially for startups more broadly

In its final section, the article pushes the discussion beyond token launches. The author says the industry is becoming more compliant, with stocks starting to move on-chain, some U.S.-listed companies actively engaging with crypto, and stablecoins already intertwined with traditional finance.

Against that backdrop, the author asks whether the sector can offer something useful to people outside crypto itself. The answer given in the piece is still the on-chain ICO model. For many startups, the article says, it could become a transparent and fair path to early-stage fundraising.

Qianshui Guanchaoyuan writes that he entered crypto in 2018 and was drawn in by token economics, especially the idea that users in an ecosystem should also be among its beneficiaries. In the author’s view, that is one of the clearest differences between Web3 and a traditional company.

If holders become the direct recipients of value, the article argues, projects can gain truly loyal users and ecosystem participants. Token allocations should go to the people creating value rather than serving as a dumping tool for a small number of market makers or project insiders.

The article closes by saying the industry can only regain outside attention, respect and innovative energy if it returns to a state of fairness, openness and transparency. The infrastructure is already in place, the author writes, and the framework has been outlined. What remains is to see who acts on it first.

This article was originally published by Bit.Fan. For more cryptocurrency news and market insights, visit www.bit.fan.
10900

Disclaimer:

The market information, project data, and third-party content displayed on this platform are for industry information sharing only and do not constitute any form of investment advice or return commitment.

Cryptocurrency trading carries high risks. Users should fully assess their risk tolerance and make independent decisions. All profits, losses, and legal responsibilities are borne by the users themselves.

Why ICOs, VC tokens and Alpha models keep failing, and what an on-chain ICO would try to fix | Bit.Fan