Blast, the Ethereum layer-2 network built by Pacman, said on Oct. 2 it was shutting down because operating costs had climbed past the revenue the network could actually keep. Then, 10 days later, NFT marketplace Blur said its site would shut on Nov. 12.
Same founder, both times: Pacman, whose real name is Tieshun Roquerre.
The most brutal figure here came from Blur. Monthly trading volume at one point hit $1.43 billion. But DefiLlama showed cumulative protocol revenue of only $2.26. Yes, $2.26. Not $22,600. Not $2.26 million. Just $2.26. The report says trading fees were sent entirely to sellers and creators, which left basically nothing for the protocol.
The piece tracks the rise, then the collapse, of a strategy built on points and token airdrops. It pulled in users. Liquidity too. Big headline volume. But it never created enough revenue to keep the projects alive.
How Blur used points to beat OpenSea
In February 2023, Pacman revealed who he was on X and summed himself up in one line: "Dropped out of high school to go through Y Combinator at 17". The report says he later attended the Massachusetts Institute of Technology and dropped out, got a $100,000 startup grant from Peter Thiel, and had earlier built decentralized domain marketplace Namebase.
Namebase raised $5 million in a round led by Paradigm and was fully acquired by Namecheap at the end of 2021. After selling it, Pacman turned to NFTs. He thought OpenSea was weak on matching speed and listing tools, so he started putting the Blur team together in early 2022.
Blur’s model was straightforward. Trading fees were zero. The real bait was points. Users who placed bids closer to the floor price, and kept those bids live longer, earned more points. Those points could later turn into BLUR token airdrops.
On Feb. 14, 2023, BLUR launched and handed out 360 million tokens in season one. At about $0.76 after listing, that worked out to roughly $270 million in value. One day later, Nansen data showed Blur’s daily trading volume had passed OpenSea for the first time. Galaxy Research said Blur’s market share later topped out at 80%, while OpenSea dropped to 15.5%.
By March, Blur’s monthly trading volume had reached about $1.43 billion. How much of that was wash trading depended on how you measured it. Dune analyst hildobby put the share at about 14%. CryptoSlam, though, said wash trading was above 80% in the two weeks after the airdrop.
Blur also slashed creator royalties, pushing them down to as low as 0.5% to lure in sellers. The Block analyst Brad Kay said Yuga Labs’ quarterly royalty revenue dropped from $8.7 million to $2.5 million, mainly because of Blur’s low-royalty setup and mining incentives. Three years later, after Blur announced the shutdown, collector Cryptobscure replied on X: "Good riddance. You ruined NFTs."
Zero fees bought volume. Points bought liquidity. But the protocol was never built to earn money from trading itself. That was the first warning sign. Pretty clear in hindsight.
Blast pulled in $510 million before the network even launched
On Nov. 20, 2023, Pacman introduced Blast. The pitch was blunt: deposit assets and earn yield automatically. The report says ETH deposited into the system was staked through Lido for about 4% annualized yield, while stablecoins were converted into USDB and tied to MakerDAO Treasury-bill yield of about 5%.
Blast reused the points formula and added invite codes. New users needed an invite code before they could deposit. Based on the official documentation cited in the article, inviters got an extra 16% of the invitee’s points, and second-level referrals got another 8%.
At that point, the layer-2 network was not even live. Deposited funds would be locked for about three months. Even so, DefiLlama showed deposits had already crossed $510 million by Nov. 26.
That setup quickly drew criticism from one of Blast’s own backers. Paradigm research head Dan Robinson wrote on X that same day that he disagreed with launching the deposit bridge before the layer 2 was ready, and also disagreed with making users wait months before they could withdraw. He said many of the marketing tactics had "cheapened the work of this serious team."
Pacman pushed back in a series of X posts. He said Blast’s yield came from Lido staking and MakerDAO Treasury-bill exposure, which gave it a real economic foundation. He also said Paradigm had not been involved in Blast’s distribution design, and that the lockup and invite-code mechanics were decisions the team made on its own.
The criticism did nothing to stop deposits. Blast mainnet launched on Feb. 29, 2024. Then on June 26, BLAST distributed 17 billion tokens in its first airdrop season. At about $0.025 at launch, Decrypt estimated the total value at roughly $430 million, with 14 billion tokens allocated to users.
Total value locked had already begun slipping before the token launch. DefiLlama data showed Blast peaked at $2.26 billion on June 6, then slid to $1.63 billion by the day the token went live. Users got the airdrop. Then they left.
About $850 million in airdrops, but revenue never caught up
The article says Blur’s first two seasons and Blast’s first season together distributed about $850 million in airdrops. Once the tokens were handed out, most were sold not long after being claimed. The report treats that point as the beginning of the decline.
The revenue numbers make the mismatch obvious. Blur produced only $2.26 in cumulative protocol revenue. Over three years, users generated about $70.82 million in fees on the platform, but because of the zero-fee design, all of that value went to sellers and creators.
Blast generated about $13.85 million in cumulative chain fees, and roughly $7.83 million of that counted as protocol revenue. By the time the shutdown was announced, the network’s 24-hour revenue had fallen to just $110.
Blast’s shutdown notice said: "The cost of maintaining operations has consistently exceeded the revenue the layer-2 network is able to capture."
Blur showed the same pattern. Monthly trading volume collapsed from $1.43 billion to less than $7 million by March 2026, a 99.5% drop. The BLUR token fell from an intraday high of $5.02 on launch day to $0.0095, down 99.8%.
DefiLlama data showed Blast’s total value locked fell from $2.26 billion to about $11.5 million by the time of the shutdown. L2BEAT, using a broader methodology, estimated about $50 million in assets still remained on-chain. The gap mainly came from ETH staked in Lido through bridge contracts.
Justin Sun? No. The report names Machi Big Brother Jeffrey Huang
The article also points to Machi Big Brother, Jeffrey Huang, as a major Blur participant. Decrypt described him as one of the biggest lenders on Blend. In June 2024, Huang called on X for Pacman to change the mining rules. Half a month later, he moved about 18.4 million BLUR to Binance. Spot On Chain estimated the loss at about $3.16 million.
The wider market was not helping either. NFT trading had been shrinking, and more Ethereum layer-2 networks kept appearing. The article says that in October alone, Abstract, StandX and ZetaChain announced shutdowns or migrations, and Farcaster changed hands for the second time this year. In the report’s telling, users and capital pulled in by token expectations did not stick around once those expectations were either fulfilled or disappointed.
The final tally was harsh: about $850 million in airdrops turned into sell pressure on the secondary market, while the projects were left holding bills they could not pay.
Two deadlines and no public next step from Pacman
Blast users can still withdraw through the official page until Oct. 26. After that, assets will not vanish, but users will have to interact directly with the bridge contract on Ethereum to get them back. The team said instructions would be published before the deadline.
On Nov. 12, blur.io will go offline and Blend will stop matching new loans. Users with active Blend loans need to repay before then. If they do not, the loans will be treated as defaults and the pledged NFTs will go to lenders. Blur said it would later release tools to help users withdraw assets from Blend.
Blur also said @blur_io is the only official account, and warned users not to trust any other notice claiming to be official.
BLUR holders still have governance control over the protocol fee switch. But with the site closing and trading activity almost gone, turning that switch on would not produce much revenue.
After Blur announced the shutdown, Cointelegraph contacted Pacman for comment, but the report says no response appeared in the coverage. And as for what he does next, the article says there is no public information.
Three years ago, Pacman used points to beat OpenSea. Two years ago, he used yield and invite codes to pull in $500 million in deposits. Now, within 10 days, he has shut down the two biggest projects he built. The article’s takeaway is plain: points can buy users, but they cannot buy revenue.


