Binance Hack Did Not Send Most Outflows to DEXs, While the Bigger Shift May Be Elsewhere

Binance Hack Did Not Send Most Outflows to DEXs, While the Bigger Shift May Be Elsewhere

N
News Editor
2026-11-03 09:23:59
Debate over whether decentralized exchanges stand to gain from Binance’s hack intensified after a Hyperliquid community account argued that traders tend to look for alternatives when trust in centralized exchanges is damaged. The backlash was immediate, but the underlying question remains: did DEXs actually absorb a meaningful share of the capital that left Binance? The data cited in the report suggests they did not. Binance disclosed net outflows of about $3.64 billion in the first roughly nine and a half hours after withdrawals resumed on Nov. 1, equal to around 2.1% of platform assets. DefiLlama later showed 24-hour net outflows peaking at about $6.3 billion on Nov. 2. Yet inflows to major rival exchanges amounted to only about one-tenth of Binance’s outflows, U.S. spot Bitcoin ETFs saw net redemptions over the next two trading days, and DEXs including Uniswap and Hyperliquid captured only a limited portion of the movement. Much of the capital appears to have gone to self-custody wallets instead. Over a longer horizon, the article argues that DEX market share has been rising, but not because of isolated CEX security failures. The more durable drivers have been traffic routed on-chain by large exchanges, the migration of more asset classes to blockchain venues, and a broader market thesis around transparent, on-chain financial infrastructure. That framing becomes more relevant as ICE moves to build a regulated trading and clearing system in the U.S. based on Hyperliquid.

Debate over centralized and decentralized exchanges picked up quickly after Binance was hacked. A Hyperliquid community account, Hyperliquid Daily, posted that traders tend to look for alternatives whenever trust in a centralized exchange is damaged, and that DEXs could benefit, with Hyperliquid now in the spotlight.

The post drew criticism almost immediately. Some users called it opportunistic, arguing that promoting a platform while the broader industry was taking losses was in poor taste. Others noted that Hyperliquid Daily is not an official Hyperliquid account and does not speak for the project. The controversy aside, the core question remains: how much of the money leaving Binance actually went to DEXs?

Where the money leaving Binance appears to have gone

Binance began restoring withdrawals in phases on Nov. 1, and outflows followed. According to Binance, the exchange recorded net outflows of about $3.64 billion in the first roughly nine and a half hours after withdrawals resumed, equal to around 2.1% of total platform assets.

DefiLlama data showed Binance’s 24-hour net outflows briefly reaching about $6.3 billion on Nov. 2 before easing.

Funds leaving Binance would typically have several destinations: other centralized exchanges, ETFs, DEXs, or users’ own self-custody wallets.

Start with other CEXs. DefiLlama data showed that combined net inflows to major exchanges including OKX, Bybit, and Bitget were only about one-tenth of Binance’s net outflows over the same period. In an effort to compete for those funds, Binance and Bitget each rolled out high-yield wealth products, with annualized returns on USDC rising above 10% at the top end.

ETFs did not absorb much of the move either. In the two trading days after the hack, U.S. spot Bitcoin ETFs posted net outflows of about $640 million and $400 million, respectively.

DEXs were at the center of the argument. Geoffrey Kendrick, global head of digital assets research at Standard Chartered, said the incident could accelerate a shift in trading toward DEXs and that Uniswap would benefit over the long run.

The market data did not show a clear surge in share capture by Uniswap. Its trading volume over the past seven days was about 20% above its 30-day weekly average, but total DEX market volume rose by roughly the same amount over the same period. That means Uniswap did not materially outperform the broader market in absorbing the flow.

Hyperliquid showed a similar pattern. DefiLlama data put net inflows to Hyperliquid at about $125 million on Nov. 2, less than one-tenth of Binance’s net outflows during the same period. Looking across the full DEX market, spot DEX volume share during the week of the hack rose to about 20.6%, but that was still below the peak seen this summer.

If rival CEXs, ETFs, and DEXs each took only a small slice, where did the rest go?

According to the author, several Binance users said they converted part of their holdings into BTC after withdrawals resumed and moved the assets into hardware wallets.

On-chain data points in the same direction. Most funds leaving Binance appear to have moved to addresses not labeled as exchanges, and a meaningful share of those addresses were likely users’ self-custody wallets. DefiLlama data also showed that Binance’s USDT balance fell much more sharply than its BTC balance after the hack, suggesting that more funds were withdrawn directly in stablecoin form.

On that basis, DEXs were not the main destination for this round of outflows. Most of the money leaving Binance appears to have gone back into users’ own control, while migration between exchanges remained limited.

DEX market share has been rising, but not because of one-off security incidents

Over a longer period, DEX market share has indeed been climbing.

In spot markets, CoinGecko’s 2025 annual report showed DEX spot volume at only about 6% of CEX spot volume at the start of 2021. By November 2025, that figure had risen to about 21%. Data from The Block showed the ratio continuing to edge higher in 2026, reaching about 23% in October. Uniswap remained the clear leader, with about $64 billion in trading volume over the past 30 days, nearly three times that of second-ranked PancakeSwap.

The path in perpetual futures has been less straightforward. In 2025, newer platforms including Hyperliquid and Lighter helped drive explosive growth in perpetual DEX trading. But much of that expansion depended on points-based incentives. Over the past year, the ratio of perpetual DEX volume to CEX volume fell from about 21% to about 12%.

Hyperliquid was an exception. Its perpetual volume in October this year was about $245 billion, equal to roughly 14% of Binance’s level, up from about 11% a year earlier.

In both spot and perpetual markets, changes in DEX share do not show a clear relationship with CEX security incidents. After FTX collapsed in November 2022, the spot DEX-to-CEX ratio did not rise in tandem. It did not return to 10% until March 2023, when U.S. regulation tightened. After the Binance hack, DEX share again moved only modestly.

Looking at the past two years, the report identifies at least three forces behind the rise in DEX share.

Large exchanges are routing users on-chain

The first comes from CEXs themselves. In May 2025, Binance launched Binance Alpha, routing user trades to PancakeSwap. CoinGecko data showed the spot DEX-to-CEX ratio jumping to a record 37.4% in June that year. PancakeSwap briefly overtook Uniswap, with market share reaching 64.5%. But once incentives faded, PancakeSwap’s monthly volume dropped 44.7% in August, and Uniswap reclaimed the top spot.

In April this year, PancakeSwap was also integrated into Coinbase’s Base App. The two largest centralized exchanges have both been directing user trading activity on-chain. That kind of traffic can produce sharp short-term growth, but whether it turns into durable market share depends on demand beyond incentives.

More asset classes are moving on-chain

The second force is the migration of trading products themselves. Early in 2025, the meme coin boom on Solana pushed DEX spot volume to a new high and drove the ratio above the range it had held for years.

Now Hyperliquid, through its HIP-3 mechanism, allows third parties to deploy perpetual contracts tied to traditional assets including equities, commodities, and foreign exchange. According to HypeBasis, open interest in HIP-3 markets stood at about $4 billion by the end of September, or roughly 23% of Hyperliquid’s total open interest. Equity-linked contracts accounted for about $2.5 billion, followed by commodities and indexes. The single largest contract by open interest was the S&P 500 perpetual.

That helps explain why Hyperliquid has continued to grow even as the broader perpetual DEX segment has cooled.

The market thesis around on-chain finance is also changing

The third force is broader and more ideological. Crypto blogger Barker Intern argued that every response to crisis in financial history has involved finding a larger backstop, while Hyperliquid is trying to build a system that needs less of a backstop as it scales. That view remains contested, but it reflects what a sizable group of on-chain users expects from DEXs.

Taken together, the report argues that changes in DEX share have been driven more by trading access points, product migration, and market narrative than by any single CEX security breach.

A possible turning point may come from regulation, not the Binance hack

The data in the first two sections suggests the Binance hack itself is unlikely to mark a turning point for DEXs. Capital did not move on-chain at scale, and DEX share only fluctuated modestly, much like the pattern seen after FTX failed.

If a turning point does emerge, it may come from somewhere else.

On the same day Binance was hacked, Intercontinental Exchange, the parent company of the New York Stock Exchange, said it had signed a definitive agreement with TradeXYZ and made a strategic investment in the company. TradeXYZ is the largest HIP-3 deployer on Hyperliquid, accounting for about 98% of open interest in the HIP-3 market.

Under the agreement, the two sides plan to build a trading and clearing system in the U.S. based on Hyperliquid, offering 24/7 perpetual contracts tied to equities, indexes, commodities, foreign exchange, and crypto assets. ICE will serve as the exclusive operator of that market, with distribution channels including an ICE-OKX joint venture. The plan still requires regulatory approval.

That move came after a different posture earlier this year. Bloomberg reported in May that executives at CME and ICE had raised concerns with Commodity Futures Trading Commission officials and members of Congress, arguing that rapidly growing crude oil perpetuals on Hyperliquid could distort global oil benchmark pricing and should be registered with the CFTC. More than five months later, ICE chose to enter the market directly as a compliant operator of on-chain perpetuals in the U.S.

On the regulatory side, CFTC Chair Michael Selig told CNBC that the Binance hack reinforced the crypto market rules proposed by the agency this month. He said the root problem was that offshore exchanges lacked the safeguards required in U.S. financial markets, and he proposed a federal option under which such platforms would register with the CFTC and comply with U.S. cybersecurity standards. He also said on-chain trading is traceable and gives regulators more room for enforcement.

If that route opens up, DEXs would be facing a market they have not previously been able to reach: retail users and institutional capital operating under U.S. regulatory protection. The effect of that shift could be larger than that of any single CEX security incident.

That brings the discussion back to the original question: will DEXs be the winners? If traditional finance is building markets on-chain, regulators are acknowledging the transparency of on-chain activity, and CEXs are also using verifiable on-chain methods to prove themselves, the eventual winners may no longer be easy to sort into a simple CEX-versus-DEX divide.

This article was originally published by Bit.Fan. For more cryptocurrency news and market insights, visit www.bit.fan.
10200

Disclaimer:

The market information, project data, and third-party content displayed on this platform are for industry information sharing only and do not constitute any form of investment advice or return commitment.

Cryptocurrency trading carries high risks. Users should fully assess their risk tolerance and make independent decisions. All profits, losses, and legal responsibilities are borne by the users themselves.

Binance Hack Did Not Send Most Outflows to DEXs, While the Bigger Shift May Be Elsewhere | Bit.Fan